Let's cut the crap: Notion AI is a glorified text editor with a ChatGPT wrapper slapped on top, and if you're paying $10/month for it, you're getting fleeced unless you're already trapped in Notion's ecosystem.
I was writing a client proposal last month when Notion AI's "summarize" feature choked on a 5-page document and gave me three bullet points that missed the entire financial section. I had to scramble to rewrite it manually, almost blowing my deadline. That's when I realized this tool is built for casual note-takers, not professionals who need reliability.
The Meat: Where Notion AI Gets Destroyed
1. The Pricing Trap: Notion AI costs $10/month on top of your existing Notion plan. That's $120/year for what's essentially a basic AI assistant. Competitors like ChatGPT Plus ($20/month) give you GPT-4, plugins, and image generation. Notion AI? You get text generation and summarization locked inside Notion. It's a classic vendor lock-in play, and it's trash for anyone who doesn't live in Notion 24/7.
2. The Laggy UI Beast: Try using the AI button in the mobile app. I tapped it three times yesterday before it registered, and then it took 4 seconds to load the prompt window. For a tool that's supposed to boost productivity, this kind of lag is unacceptable. It feels like they bolted on the AI features without optimizing the core experience.
<3>3. The Feature Gap: No code interpreter, no advanced data analysis, no API for custom workflows (unlike competitors). You're stuck with what Notion gives you, and that list is painfully short compared to dedicated AI tools.💡 Pro Tip: If you're already on Notion's free plan, use the AI credits they give you for free (it's like 20 responses). Never pay for the AI add-on unless you're a heavy Notion user who needs AI inside your notes daily. Otherwise, use a dedicated tool.The Data: Raw Comparison
| Feature | Notion AI | ChatGPT Plus | Claude Pro |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $10/month (add-on) | $20/month | $20/month |
| Core AI Model | GPT-3.5/4 (obscured) | GPT-4 | Claude 3 Opus |
| Context Window | Limited by Notion block | 128K tokens | 200K tokens |
| Integration | Only inside Notion | Web, API, plugins | Web, API |
| Best For | Notion power users | General AI tasks | Long-form writing |
The Verdict
Buy Notion AI only if you're a Notion addict who needs AI features directly in your notes and databases, and you're willing to overpay for the convenience. Otherwise, avoid it like the plague. For everyone else, get ChatGPT Plus for general use or Claude Pro for writing—they're actual AI tools, not a feature add-on.
👉 Check Price / Try FreeOriginally published at Nexus AI
Top comments (0)