Let's Get Real: Notion AI is a Rip-off... Until You Actually Use It
Here's the hard truth: Notion AI costs $10/month on top of your existing Notion plan. That's $120/year for AI features that competitors like ChatGPT Plus offer for $20/month. On paper, it's a scam. But after using it daily for three months, I've realized something: Notion AI isn't an AI tool—it's a productivity steroid injected directly into your workspace. The real question isn't "Is it worth it?" but "Can you afford NOT to have your notes and docs thinking for you?"
The Meat: Where Notion AI Actually Wins (And Fails Spectacularly)
1. Context is King, and Notion AI Owns the Throne
ChatGPT doesn't know about your client meeting notes from last Tuesday. Google Docs AI can't reference your project timeline. Notion AI lives inside your actual workspace. I was preparing a quarterly report and typed "/ai summarize project risks"—it instantly pulled data from six different pages I'd created over three months. Competitors make you copy-paste; Notion AI just knows.
💡 Pro Tip: Create a "Meeting Notes" database with AI-generated summaries. After every call, dump your raw notes, hit the AI button, and get bullet-point takeaways in 3 seconds. Saves me 30 minutes per meeting.
2. The Laggy Slash-Command That Almost Made Me Quit
Here's my specific annoyance: that damn slash command. Type "/ai" and wait. And wait. Sometimes it pops up instantly; other times there's a 2-3 second delay where you're staring at a blank screen. For a tool that costs $120/year, this basic UI element should be flawless. I timed it: 1.8 seconds average response time. In a world where ChatGPT responds in milliseconds, this feels like using dial-up internet.
3. The Database Integration That Saved My Agency
Personal anecdote: I almost lost a $15k client because their project requirements were scattered across 12 different Notion pages. Competitor AI tools couldn't help—they don't understand Notion's database structure. Notion AI analyzed all related pages, identified three conflicting deadlines the client hadn't noticed, and generated a unified project plan in 45 seconds. The client signed the extension that afternoon.
The Data: Cold, Hard Comparison
| Feature | Notion AI | ChatGPT Plus | Google Workspace AI | Craft Docs AI |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $10/month (add-on) | $20/month | $30/month (Business) | $6/month |
| Context Awareness | Your entire workspace | Current chat only | Current document only | Current document only |
| Database Integration | Native (killer feature) | None | Basic | None |
| Response Speed | Slow (1-3 sec) | Fast (<1 sec) | Medium | Fast |
| Output Quality | Excellent for docs | Best overall | Good for emails | Basic |
| Learning Curve | None (if you use Notion) | Low | Medium | Low |
The Verdict: Who Should Actually Buy This?
Buy Notion AI immediately if: You live in Notion for work (5+ hours daily), manage complex projects with databases, and need AI that understands your workspace context. The database integration alone justifies the cost for power users.
Avoid it like trash if: You're a casual Notion user, only need general AI chat, or can't tolerate the occasional UI lag. Get ChatGPT Plus instead—it's cheaper and faster for general tasks.
Bottom line: Notion AI is the overpriced middle child that somehow became the family favorite. It's not the best AI, but it's the best AI for Notion. And if you're already all-in on Notion, that distinction matters more than the price tag.
Originally published at Nexus AI
Top comments (0)