DEV Community

Shashank Agarwal
Shashank Agarwal

Posted on Edited on Fully Autonomous

Beyond Accuracy: Choosing the Right Dimensions of AI Agent Quality

Updated October 29, 2026. The old title used an earlier scorer count. This revision distinguishes quality dimensions from catalog entries, updates the library reference and removes unsupported coverage guarantees.

A single accuracy score cannot explain every aspect of an AI agent’s behavior. A response can be supported by its source but fail to complete the task. A correct answer can follow redundant paid tool calls. Different questions need different evidence.

Choose dimensions from the task

Start with the behavior your application needs to deliver:

Dimension Example evaluation question Relevant evidence
Task outcome Did the agent complete the requested task? Task, final result and success criteria
Answer support Are material claims supported? Response and relevant source context
Instruction adherence Did it stay within its assigned boundaries? Instructions and captured actions
Tool use Were the selected operations and inputs appropriate? Available tool definitions, calls and results
Efficiency Were calls repeated without useful progress? Timings, usage metadata and captured operations
User experience Was the answer relevant and understandable? Conversation and a reviewed rubric

These are evaluation questions, not a claim that one product contains a separately named scorer for every row. Check a scorer’s actual definition and input requirements before using it.

Catalog size and evaluation coverage are different

I’m Shashank Agarwal, founder and CEO of Noveum AI and creator of API.market. On October 29, 2026, Noveum’s published library lists 112 evaluators across 15 categories.

That is a catalog count. It is not 112 independent dimensions, nor a promise that all checks run automatically on every response. Choose compatible checks for the task and available data.

The library includes model-backed, deterministic, audio-model and signal-based checks. Their outputs can be numeric, boolean or labels. Preserve the native output and saved pass decision rather than forcing every result onto one scale.

Avoid an aggregate that hides the failure

Suppose an article-summary agent returns fluent prose after extracting the wrong page. A fluency result may be favorable while the task fails. Inspect the source URL, extracted material and summary support separately.

Some conditions may be release gates; others are useful diagnostics. Define those roles explicitly. A weighted average can hide a critical failed condition if several less important scores are high.

Noveum workflow: capture, prepare, evaluate, investigate, test and review.

Validate judgments and inspect evidence

A system prompt defines requirements; it does not prove factual correctness. Use appropriate context or reviewed references for the checks that need them. Inspect a sample of passing cases as well as failures to understand missed problems and false positives.

Signals about privacy or policy handling can identify issues for review. They do not by themselves establish compliance with a legal framework. Likewise, predicted satisfaction is different from measured customer feedback.

Keep the application version, dataset selection, check configuration and observed results together. The production monitoring guide explains how these pieces connect to investigation and candidate testing.

Follow my work on LinkedIn. This refresh was drafted with AI assistance.

Top comments (0)