kanta13jp1

Posted on Apr 27

Public Memos vs Notion Pages: Why 'Publish Anything' Beats 'Publish Perfectly'

#notion #productivity #saas #webdev

Public Memos vs Notion Pages: Why "Publish Anything" Beats "Publish Perfectly"

The Hidden Cost of Publishing on Notion

Publishing something on Notion:

Create the page
Format it (headings, tables, callouts...)
Add a cover image
Share → Publish on web
Copy the link

Five steps. Notion is designed for publishing polished pages.

Jibun Kaisha's Public Memo feature starts from a different premise: publish what you're thinking right now, in whatever state it's in.

What Public Memos Are

Public Memos sit between a Twitter/X post and a Notion page:

No character limit (unlike X's 280)
No formatting required (unlike Notion's rich editor expectations)
Instant publish (no approval flow, no publish settings)
Shareable by URL (unique public URL per memo)
Editable after posting (update the content, URL stays the same)

Use cases:

· Learning logs (what I understood today)
· Idea capture (unstructured thinking)
· Work diary (what I actually did)
· Short technical notes (commands, config values)
· Reading highlights (a passage worth sharing)

Design Comparison: Notion Pages vs Public Memos

Dimension	Notion Pages	Public Memos
Steps to publish	5–8	1 (write and submit)
Formatting expected	Yes (headings, structure)	No
URL domain	notion.so/workspace/xxx	your-domain.web.app/memo/xxx
Post-edit behavior	Immediate update	Immediate update
Search indexing	Notion domain only	Your domain → Google indexable
Version history	Yes (Pro+)	No
Comments	Yes	No
Image embeds	◎	△ (text-focused)
Templates	Yes	No
Monthly cost	$16+	$0 (built into Jibun Kaisha)

Why "No Formatting Required" Matters

Notion Pages create a psychological pressure: if I'm publishing this, it should look good.

The result:

Time spent formatting instead of thinking
Posts delayed because "it's not formatted yet"
Drafts that never get published

Public Memos remove this pressure entirely. The design assumption is: fragments are fine, unfinished is fine.

This is Austin Kleon's "Show Your Work" philosophy — share the process, not just the finished product.

Implementation: Supabase + Flutter

-- page_shares: the public memo backing table
CREATE TABLE page_shares (
  id UUID PRIMARY KEY DEFAULT gen_random_uuid(),
  user_id UUID REFERENCES auth.users,
  title TEXT,
  content TEXT NOT NULL,
  slug TEXT UNIQUE,           -- URL identifier
  is_public BOOLEAN DEFAULT true,
  view_count INTEGER DEFAULT 0,
  created_at TIMESTAMPTZ DEFAULT NOW(),
  updated_at TIMESTAMPTZ DEFAULT NOW()
);

-- Public memos readable by everyone
CREATE POLICY "public memos are readable by all"
  ON page_shares FOR SELECT
  USING (is_public = true);

-- Only owner can write
CREATE POLICY "users can edit own memos"
  ON page_shares FOR ALL
  USING (auth.uid() = user_id);

// Flutter: publish in one step
Future<void> publishMemo(String content) async {
  final slug = generateSlug(); // short UUID
  await supabase.from('page_shares').insert({
    'content': content,
    'slug': slug,
    'user_id': supabase.auth.currentUser!.id,
  });
  // Live at: /memo/$slug
}

The SEO Angle

Notion's public pages live at notion.so. SEO value accrues to Notion's domain, not yours.

Jibun Kaisha Public Memos live at your-domain.web.app/memo/xxx. SEO value accumulates on your domain.

Over time, publishing many memos on a topic creates long-tail keyword coverage on your own domain — a compounding asset that doesn't exist when you publish on Notion.

When Notion Pages Are Still the Right Choice

Public Memos don't replace everything. Notion Pages win when:

You need a polished document (spec docs, proposals, portfolios)
Rich content is required (images, video, embeds)
You want discussion via comments (gathering feedback)
You need templates (reusable structures)
Multiple people are collaborating (team editing)

Rule of thumb: "thinking fragments and process updates" → Public Memos. "Finished content worth polishing" → Notion Pages.

Summary

Notion Pages are optimized for publishing polished content
Public Memos are optimized for publishing unpolished thinking immediately
Removing formatting cost increases publication frequency, which compounds
SEO value on your own domain vs. Notion's domain is a meaningful long-term difference

Publishing imperfect thoughts consistently beats publishing perfect content occasionally.

Jibun Kaisha — integrating the best of 21 competitors into one life management app

Live: https://my-web-app-b67f4.web.app/

DEV Community