DEV Community

LaunchSignal
LaunchSignal

Posted on

Where my agent stops: the self-promotion rules on six free launch channels

I've been letting a coding agent take over more of my release chores: changelog, screenshots, the one-line description, the listing payload. The obvious next ask is "and post it to the usual places." Before I hand that over, I wanted to know where each free channel draws its own line on self-promotion and on automation, using only the rules each one publishes about itself.

So I read the official pages for six community channels on November 14, 2026, and wrote down what they say. Where a page is silent, I write "not stated." Where a fetch got a challenge page instead of the content, I write "blocked."

Hacker News: write it yourself, post it yourself

The HN guidelines are the most direct I found. "Please don't use HN primarily for promotion. It's ok to post your own stuff part of the time, but the primary use of the site should be for curiosity." Two lines later: "Please don't put generated text in HN posts. Write your text yourself—HN is for sharing between humans. For the same reason, please don't automate posting." They also say "Don't solicit upvotes, comments, or submissions."

The Show HN guidelines add the launch-specific rules. Show HN "is for something you've made that other people can play with." Blog posts, sign-up pages, newsletters, and lists are off topic. "The project should be non-trivial. Don't post quickly-generated one-offs; anybody can do that now." The project has to be something "you've worked on personally and which you're around to discuss." The page asks you to make it easy to try, "ideally without barriers such as signups or emails," and says every Show HN appears on /shownew and moves to /show once it clears "a small points threshold."

The HN FAQ is blunt about vote requests: "We penalize or ban submissions, accounts, and sites that break this rule." It also notes that green usernames mean a new account.

For my agent, that's clear: it can help me check that the thing is actually tryable without a signup. It doesn't write the post, and it doesn't submit it.

Lobsters: a ratio and a waiting period

Lobsters' About page has the only numeric self-promotion rule I found: "As a rule of thumb, self-promo should be less than a quarter of one's stories and comments in the last year." It frames the problem as using the site "as a write-only tool for product announcements or driving traffic to their work."

New users, defined as the first 70 days, "are not allowed to submit self-promo," and they can't use a set of tags that includes show. Accounts come through an invitation tree, which the page says helps identify voting rings. One detail I didn't expect: "Domains used for marketing analytics are banned and tracking parameters are removed from links." My habit of adding utm_ tags to every link does nothing there.

Lobsters is a place where the account's history counts. An agent can't speed that up, and I wouldn't want it to try.

Reddit: the community's rules come first

The sitewide Reddit Rules say each community's culture is shaped "by the community rules enforced by moderators." Rule 2 reads: "Abide by community rules. Participate authentically in communities where you have a personal interest, and do not spam or engage in disruptive behaviors (including content manipulation)." Rule 5: "Be authentic... do not intentionally mislead others."

I tried to read Reddit's help-center article on spam for more detail, and my fetch got a challenge page, so that one is blocked rather than missing. A sitewide numeric self-promotion ratio is not stated on the rules page I could read. The practical answer is the one most makers already know: each subreddit's sidebar is the real rulebook, and it differs from one subreddit to the next.

DEV: AI help is allowed, with conditions

DEV's Terms have a short content policy: posts should be "on-topic, of high-quality, and... not designed primarily for the purposes of promotion or creating backlinks," and "must contain substantial content," not just a link to the full post elsewhere.

DEV is also the only channel here with a published policy on AI-written posts. The Guidelines for AI-assisted Articles, last updated by the DEV Team on April 8, 2024, allow AI-assisted and AI-generated articles if they're written in good faith, disclose the AI help, and are "checked for factual accuracy before publishing." The same page says those articles should not "Promote any business, program, or course (including your own)," and it asks people not to use bots or AI to generate comments.

That changes how I write here. A draft that started with an agent has to be one I can stand behind line by line, with the disclosure in the post and the product kept out of it.

Peerlist: people launch, agencies don't

Peerlist's Launchpad Rules and Guidelines start with "We have zero tolerance for spamming," which covers DMing strangers for upvotes, re-sharing your launch link over and over, and asking for upvotes under other people's posts. "Only individual profiles are allowed to launch projects," with a valid name and profile picture. And: "SEO marketing agencies are strictly prohibited from launching projects on behalf of their clients or customers."

That last line isn't about AI, but it answers the same question. Someone launching on your behalf isn't the same as you launching.

Indie Hackers: mostly not stated

I looked for posting or self-promotion guidelines on Indie Hackers' official pages and didn't find a dedicated one. /guidelines returned a 404, and /faq redirected to /about. The Terms prohibit running "any form of auto-responder or 'spam' on the Services, or any processes that run or are activated while you are not logged into the Services." A self-promotion ratio is not stated.

What I'm handing the agent, and what I'm not

Read together, these rules mostly agree, even though each is worded differently. The community channels want a person who made the thing, who shows up in the thread, and who doesn't recruit votes. HN rules out generated post text and automated posting outright. DEV allows AI help if you disclose it and keep the post from being an ad. Lobsters and Peerlist both care about who the account belongs to and how long it has been around.

So my split is:

  • Agent: check that the product URL works without a signup, draft the one-line description I'll reuse everywhere, collect screenshots, keep a sheet of each channel's rules with the date I read them, and fill submission forms on sites built for listings.
  • Me: write the Show HN text, decide whether a subreddit is one I actually belong to, post from my own account, and stay in the comments.

The lines move, so I re-read the pages before each launch rather than trusting my notes.

I drafted this with help from an AI assistant and checked every quote against the linked pages on November 14, 2026.

Top comments (0)