Matt Angelosanto for LogRocket

Posted on Jul 16, 2021 • Originally published at blog.logrocket.com

Pinia vs. Vuex: Is Pinia a good replacement for Vuex?

#vue #webdev

Written by Emmanuel John ✏️

Introduction

Pinia, a lightweight state management library for Vue.js, has gained recent popularity. It uses the new reactivity system in Vue 3 to build an intuitive and fully typed state management library.

Pinia’s success can be attributed to its unique features (extensibility, store module organization, grouping of state changes, multiple stores creation, and so on) for managing stored data.

On the other hand, Vuex is also a popular state management library built for the Vue framework, and it is the recommended library for state management by the Vue core team. Vuex is highly focused on application scalability, developer ergonomics, and confidence. It is based on the same flux architecture as Redux.

In this article, we will make a comparison between Pinia and Vuex. We will analyze the setup, community strengths, and performance of both frameworks. We’ll also look at new changes in Vuex 5 compared to Pinia 2.

The code snippets used in this article are based on the Vue 3 Composition API.

Setup

Pinia setup

It is easy to get started with Pinia because it only requires installation and creating a store.

To install Pinia, you can run the following command in your terminal:

yarn add pinia@next
# or with npm
npm install pinia@next

This version is compatible with Vue 3. If you are looking for the version compatible with Vue 2.x, check the v1 branch.

Pinia is a wrapper around the Vue 3 Composition API. Hence you don’t have to initialize it as a plugin unless there’s a situation where you want Vue devtools support, SSR support, and webpack code splitting:

//app.js
import { createPinia } from 'pinia'
app.use(createPinia())

In the snippet above, you add Pinia to the Vue.js project so that you can use Pinia’s global object in your code.

To create a store, you call the defineStore method with an object containing the states, actions, and getters needed to create a basic store:

// stores/todo.js
import { defineStore } from 'pinia'

export const useTodoStore = defineStore({
  id: 'todo',
  state: () => ({ count: 0, title: "Cook noodles", done:false })
})

Vuex setup

Vuex is also easy to set up, requiring installation and creating a store.

To install Vuex, you can run the following commands in your terminal:

npm install vuex@next --save
# or with yarn
yarn add vuex@next --save

To create a store, you call the createStore method with an object containing the states, actions, and getters needed to create a basic store:

//store.js
import {createStore} from 'vuex'
const useStore = createStore({
  state: {
    todos: [
      { id: 1, title: '...', done: true }
    ]
  },
  getters: {
    doneTodos (state) {
      return state.todos.filter(todo => todo.done)
    }
  }
})

To access the Vuex global object, you need to add Vuex to the root Vue.js project file as follows:

//index.js
import { createApp } from 'vue'
import App from './App.vue'
import {useStore} from './store'
createApp(App).use(store).mount('#app')

Usage

Vuex and Pinia access their stores slightly differently.

Pinia usage

Using Pinia, the store can be accessed as follows:

export default defineComponent({
  setup() {
    const todo = useTodoStore()

    return {
      // gives access only to specific state
      state: computed(() => todo.title),
    }
  },
})

Notice that the state object of the store is omitted while accessing its properties.

Vuex usage

Using Vuex, the store can be accessed as follows:

import { computed } from 'vue'
export default {
  setup () {
    const store = useStore()

    return {
      // access a state in computed function
      count: computed(() => store.state.count),

      // access a getter in computed function
      double: computed(() => store.getters.double)
    }
  }
}

Community and ecosystem strength

Pinia has a small community at the time of writing this article, which results in few contributions and fewer solutions on Stack Overflow.

Due to Pinia’s popularity beginning early last year, and its progress so far, its community is fast growing. Hopefully, there will be more contributors and solutions on Pinia soon.

Vuex, being the recommended state management library by the Vue.js core team, has a large community with major contributions from the core team members. Solutions to Vuex bugs are readily available on Stack Overflow.

Learning curve and documentation

Both state management libraries are fairly easy to learn since they have great documentation and learning resources on YouTube and third-party blogs. Their learning curve is easier for developers with previous experience working with Flux architecture libraries like Redux, MobX, Recoil, and more.

Both libraries’ documentations are great and written in a manner friendly to both experienced and new developers.

GitHub ratings

At the time of writing this article, Pinia has two major releases: v1 and v2, with v2 having over 1.6K stars on GitHub. It’s inarguably one of the fastest-growing state management libraries in the Vue.js ecosystem, given that it was initially released in 2019 and it’s relatively new.

Meanwhile, from the creation date of Vuex until now, the Vuex library has made five stable releases. Although v5 is in its experimental stage, Vuex’s v4 is the most stable release so far and has about 26.3K stars on GitHub.

Performance

Both Pinia and Vuex are super fast, and in some cases your web application will be faster when using Pinia compared to Vuex. This performance boost can be attributed to Pinia’s extremely light weight. Pinia weighs around 1KB.

Although Pinia is built with Vue devtools support, some features like time traveling and editing are still not supported because Vue devtools doesn't expose the necessary APIs. This is worth noting when developmental speed and debugging are of more preference for your project.

Comparing Pinia 2 with Vuex 4

Pinia draws these comparisons to Vuex 3 and 4:

Mutations no longer exist. They were very often perceived as extremely verbose. They initially brought devtools integration but that is no longer an issue.
No need to create custom complex wrappers to support TypeScript, everything is typed and the API is designed in a way to leverage TS type inference as much as possible.

These are additional insights Pinia makes in the comparison between its state management library and Vuex:

Pinia has no support for nested stores. Instead, it allows you to create stores as you need them. However, stores can still be nested implicitly by importing and using a store inside another
Stores are namespaced automatically as they are defined. Hence there is no need to namespace modules explicitly
Pinia allows you to build multiple stores and let your bundler code split them automatically
Pinia allows getters to be used in other getters
Pinia allows grouping of changes in the devtools timeline using $patch:

    this.$patch((state) => {
        state.posts.push(post)
        state.user.postsCount++
      })
      .catch(error){
        this.errors.push(error)
      }

Comparing Pinia 2 (currently in alpha) with Vuex, we can deduce that Pinia is ahead of Vuex 4.

The Vue.js core team has an open RFC for Vuex 5 similar to the one used by Pinia. Currently, Vuex goes through RFC to gather as much feedback from the community as possible. Hopefully, the stable release of Vuex 5 will outperform Pinia 2

According to the creator of Pinia (Eduardo San Martin Morote), who is also part of the Vue.js core team and actively participates in the design of Vuex, Pinia and Vuex have more similarities than differences:

Pinia tries to stay as close to Vuex's philosophy as possible. It was designed to test out a proposal for the next iteration of Vuex and it was a success as we currently have an open RFC for Vuex 5 with an API very similar to the one used by Pinia. My personal intention with this project is to redesign the experience of using a global Store while keeping the approachable philosophy of Vue. I keep the API of Pinia as close as Vuex as it keeps moving forward to make it easy for people to migrate to Vuex or to even fusion both projects (under Vuex) in the future.

Although Pinia is good enough to replace Vuex, replacing Vuex is not its aim, hence Vuex remains the recommended state management library for Vue.js applications.

Vuex and Pinia Pros and Cons

Vuex Pros

Supports debugging features like time traveling and editing
Suitable for large-scale and high-complexity Vue.js projects

Vuex Cons

As of Vue 3, the getter's result is not cached as the computed property does
Vuex 4 has some problems associated with type safety

Pinia Pros

Full TypeScript support: adding TypeScript is easy compared to adding TypeScript in Vuex
Extremely lightweight (weighing around 1KB)
The store’s actions are dispatched as regular function calls rather than using the dispatch method or MapAction helper function, which is common in Vuex
Has support for multiple stores
Has support for Vue devtools, SSR, and webpack code splitting

Pinia Cons

No support for debugging features like time traveling and editing

When to use Pinia and when to use Vuex

From my personal experience, due to Pinia’s light weight, it is suitable for small- and medium-scale applications. It is also suitable for low-complexity Vue.js projects since some debugging features like time traveling and editing are still not supported.

Using Vuex for small- to medium-scale Vue.js projects is overkill because its weight contributes heavily to performance reduction. Hence, Vuex is suitable for large-scale and high-complexity Vue.js projects.

Conclusion

In this article, we drew comparisons between Vuex and Pinia and highlighted their best features, documentation, community strength, learning curves, and some pitfalls discovered in both libraries at the time of writing.

Vuex 4 and Pinia are similar in most ways, and they can be used to accomplish the same tasks.

Overall, one is not better than the other — they both achieve the desired goal. It all depends on your use case and preference.

Also, keep in mind that the creator of Pinia has stated that the aim of Pinia is not to replace Vuex. Rather, it aims to make it easy for developers to migrate to Vuex or to even fuse both projects (under Vuex) in the future.

Experience your Vue apps exactly how a user does

Debugging Vue.js applications can be difficult, especially when there are dozens, if not hundreds of mutations during a user session. If you’re interested in monitoring and tracking Vue mutations for all of your users in production, try LogRocket.

LogRocket is like a DVR for web apps, recording literally everything that happens in your Vue apps including network requests, JavaScript errors, performance problems, and much more. Instead of guessing why problems happen, you can aggregate and report on what state your application was in when an issue occurred.

The LogRocket Vuex plugin logs Vuex mutations to the LogRocket console, giving you context around what led to an error, and what state the application was in when an issue occurred.

Modernize how you debug your Vue apps — start monitoring for free.

DEV Community