Hello, I'm Maneshwar. I'm working on FreeDevTools online currently building **one place for all dev tools, cheat codes, and TLDRs* — a free, open-source hub where developers can quickly find and use tools without any hassle of searching all over the internet.
When it comes to authentication and authorization, three major protocols come up: OAuth, SAML, and OpenID Connect.
Each serves a unique purpose, and knowing the differences helps in picking the right one for your application.
What is SAML?
SAML (Security Assertion Markup Language) is an open standard used for authentication and authorization between identity providers (IdP
) and service providers (SP).
It is commonly used in enterprise settings for Single Sign-On (SSO).
How SAML Works:
- A user (the principal) requests access to a service provider (e.g., Gmail, Microsoft 365).
- The service provider asks an identity provider (IdP) for authentication.
- The IdP verifies the user and sends a SAML assertion (a message confirming authentication).
- The service provider grants or denies access based on this assertion.
Key Features of SAML:
- Uses XML to transmit authentication data.
- Best suited for enterprise-level applications.
- Works well for SSO (Single Sign-On), reducing the need to log in multiple times.
- Strong encryption makes it secure for enterprise authentication.
What is OAuth?
OAuth (Open Authorization) is a protocol for authorization that allows third-party applications to access user data without exposing passwords.
It is widely used in mobile apps, APIs, and web applications.
How OAuth Works:
- A user wants to grant access to a third-party app (e.g., Trello accessing Gmail contacts).
- The app (consumer) requests authorization from the user.
- The service provider (e.g., Google) provides an access token after the user consents.
- The third-party app uses this token to access the user’s data.
Key Features of OAuth:
- Uses JSON for communication instead of XML.
- Primarily focused on authorization, not authentication.
- Ideal for mobile apps, APIs, and IoT devices.
- Uses access tokens for secure, temporary access.
What is OpenID Connect?
OpenID Connect (OIDC) is an authentication layer built on top of OAuth 2.0. While OAuth handles authorization, OpenID Connect ensures authentication.
How OpenID Connect Works:
- A user logs in using an identity provider (e.g., Google, Facebook).
- The identity provider authenticates the user and sends an ID token to the application.
- The application grants access without storing the user’s credentials.
Key Features of OpenID Connect:
- Uses OAuth 2.0 for authentication.
- Best suited for applications needing secure federated authentication.
- Uses JSON Web Tokens (JWTs) for secure token exchange.
SAML vs OAuth vs OpenID: The Key Differences
| Feature | SAML | OAuth | OpenID Connect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Authentication & Authorization | Authorization only | Authentication |
| Data Format | XML | JSON | JSON |
| Ideal For | Enterprise SSO | APIs, mobile apps, IoT | Third-party authentication |
| Token Type | SAML Assertion | Access Token | ID Token |
| Encryption | Strong encryption | Less focus on encryption | Uses JWT with signing |
When to Use Each Protocol
- Use SAML when securing enterprise applications with SSO.
- Use OAuth when granting secure access to user data in APIs and mobile apps.
- Use OpenID Connect when integrating third-party authentication services.
Conclusion
Understanding OAuth vs SAML vs OpenID Connect helps you pick the right protocol for your needs.
If you need SSO for enterprise, go with SAML.
If your app needs secure access to user data, choose OAuth.
For third-party authentication, OpenID Connect is the best choice.
I’ve been building FreeDevTools.
A collection of UI/UX-focused tools crafted to simplify workflows, save time, and reduce friction in searching tools/materials.
Any feedback or contributors are welcome!
It’s online, open-source, and ready for anyone to use.
👉 Check it out: FreeDevTools
⭐ Star it on GitHub: freedevtools
Let’s make it even better together.
Top comments (0)