🧠 How to Code Review Without Losing Your Mind (or Your Team’s Respect)

A no-nonsense guide to giving and receiving feedback that actually helps

👀 Why Code Reviews Matter

Code reviews are more than just nitpicking tabs vs. spaces. They’re about sharing knowledge, improving quality, and building trust. Whether you’re a fresh hire or the architect, the moment you click “Request Review,” you’re inviting someone into your thought process.

And when you’re the reviewer? You’re stepping into the code’s story, trying to understand not just what it does — but whyit was written that way.

Done right, code reviews elevate the whole team. Done wrong, they frustrate everyone and ship bugs.

🎯 The Goal of a Code Review Is Not Perfection

Let’s get one thing straight: your job as a reviewer is not to rewrite the code. It’s to improve it.

You’re looking for:

• Correctness: Does it work as intended? Could it break something else?

• Clarity: Can someone else understand this six months later?

• Consistency: Does it follow project conventions?

• Scalability: Will it still work when more users or data are added?

• Security: Are there any obvious vulnerabilities or edge cases?

✅ Example (Clarity):

// Less clear
const a = b * c - d;
// Better
const finalPrice = discount * quantity - couponValue;

✅ Example (Consistency):

If your team uses camelCase for function names:

// Inconsistent
function fetch_user_data() {}
// Consistent
function fetchUserData() {}

👂 Read the Code Before You Judge

Slow down. Don’t skim the diff and start commenting like you’re on Twitter. First, try to understand the problem the code is solving.

• Read the PR description.

• Check the related ticket or task.

• Skim the changes as a whole before going line by line.

If the “why” isn’t obvious, ask. Clarification > Assumption.

💬 Feedback Isn’t War — It’s a Conversation

You’re not a linter. You’re a teammate.

Use neutral language:

• Instead of: “This is wrong.”

• Try: “Can you help me understand why this approach was taken?”

Use suggestions, not commands:

• “Consider renaming this for clarity.”

• “Would using a loop here improve readability?”

Don’t forget to praise good work:

• “Nice use of forEach loop here.”

• “Great job simplifying the logic!”

🧠 For the Reviewer: Be Kind, Be Curious, Be Clear

• 🧪 Test Locally if You Can: Don’t just rely on static diff views.

• 🧼 Review in Chunks: Don’t try to go through 500 lines at once.

• 📅 Review Promptly: A slow review delays everyone. Be respectful of people’s timelines.

• 🤔 Think Contextually: Don’t overcorrect. Some imperfections are okay if they don’t harm the outcome.

✅ Example (Security):

If you see this:

fetch(`https://api.example.com/user/${userId}`)

…ask if the API endpoint needs to be sanitized or authenticated. Even general codebases can leak private info if unchecked.

🙇 For the Author: Feedback Is a Gift (Yes, Really)

• Don’t take it personally. Your code ≠ your worth.

• Respond with openness: “Thanks for the catch!” goes a long way.

• If you disagree, explain respectfully. Defending a decision is part of the collaboration process.

And always say thank you. They took time to review your work.

🧩 Tips for Teams to Make Code Reviews Smoother

• ✅ Define what must be reviewed (e.g. new features, infra changes).

• 🧾 Have a checklist (e.g. test cases, naming, error handling).

• 🧠 Keep PRs small. Big ones invite procrastination.

• 💬 Use PR templates to give context.

• 🙌 Encourage pair reviews occasionally — especially for juniors.

• ⏳ Timebox feedback sessions to avoid burnouts.

🛠️ Code Reviews Are Culture

More than a practice, code reviews reflect the culture of your team:

• Is it safe to ask questions?

• Are juniors encouraged to review?

• Is feedback appreciated, or feared?

Great codebases come from great code review habits. And great habits come from teams that value respect, collaboration, and clarity.

👋 Coming Soon…

Love working with React Native? I’m writing a dedicated React Native Code Review Guide — from optimizing renders to catching native quirks before they hit production.

Stay tuned.

☕ Enjoyed this piece?

I write about team culture, software engineering, and dev life. If this helped you, consider buying me a coffee so I can keep writing honest, practical blogs.