DEV Community

Maildoer Team
Maildoer Team

Posted on

The follow-up question is the real spec: a homework sheet for a dog trainer

Most "write me a template" requests are really about the second message, the one that arrives three weeks later and only makes sense if you remember the first.

I build Maildoer, an email assistant, so I spend a lot of time thinking about that second message. Here's a labelled hypothetical I keep coming back to, because it shows the problem without any code at all.

The setup

Say you run a small dog-training business: Saturday group classes and a few private sessions. After each session you email the owner a short recap.

Three weeks later, one owner writes:

"She's pulling on the lead again. What was the thing you said to do with the treat?"

That email contains almost nothing. The answer lives in your recap from week one. If the recap was a friendly paragraph, you now have to dig, reread, and guess which "thing" they mean.

The fix is in the first email, not the reply

Write the recap so the follow-up can be answered by pointing at one line. A homework sheet that works:

Dog: [name]        Session: [date, group/private]
1. What we practised:   [skill, e.g. loose-lead walking]
2. The exact cue:       [word + hand signal]
3. Reward rule:         [when the treat goes in, and where]
4. Homework:            [minutes per day, where]
5. Stop if:             [sign to back off]
Next step when 4 is easy: [one sentence]
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Line 3 is the one people forget to write down. "Treat at your left knee the moment the lead goes slack, not after she comes back" is a rule someone can follow from memory. "Reward good walking" isn't.

Rules I'd follow for the sheet

  • One skill per sheet. If you practised two things, send two short sheets. Follow-ups usually mention one problem.
  • Copy the cue exactly. If you said "with me", don't write "heel" in the recap. Owners repeat what they read.
  • Write the "stop if" line. It prevents the most common follow-up: "I kept going and it got worse."
  • Number the lines. Then your reply can be "Back to line 3, and halve the distance" instead of a new essay.
  • Keep the next step conditional. "When five minutes is easy, move to the park entrance" stops owners skipping ahead.

Answering the vague follow-up

When "what was the thing with the treat?" arrives, the reply is short because the first email did the work:

"That's line 3 from the 2 October sheet: treat at your left knee the moment the lead goes slack. Pulling again usually means the walk got harder before the habit set. Go back to the quiet street for a week, then try the park entrance again."

Notice what that reply needs: the date of the earlier sheet, the exact rule, and the place they'd reached. None of it is in the new message.

Where Maildoer fits

This is the case I care about most when building Maildoer. You email a task to do@maildoer.com, with attachments if you have them, and when the same person writes again, the new message is read together with their earlier ones. A trainer could send "draft my reply to this" with the owner's one-line question, and the draft can point back to the right sheet instead of starting from zero. You can also reply to a result to adjust it without re-explaining.

It's not magic, and it doesn't replace writing a good first recap. The sheet above helps whether or not you ever try the tool.

Takeaway for anyone designing templates

If you're building a form, a checklist, or a bot: collect the follow-up questions first. They tell you which fields the original message was missing. For a dog trainer, it was the reward rule. In your domain, it's probably something just as small.

If you want to try it, every email address gets 100 credits on first use: https://maildoer.com

Top comments (0)