DEV Community

Cover image for How to Sell a Domain Name: Where Buyers Look and What Fees Take
Mark Fulton
Mark Fulton

Posted on

How to Sell a Domain Name: Where Buyers Look and What Fees Take

Selling a domain is easy to start and hard to finish. Listing takes five minutes. Getting paid takes a buyer who trusts you.

I used to be a domain reseller and blogger, so I have sold names the slow way. Here is what I check before I list one.

Free stuff: grab these first

  • The free domain value checker on 199.domains. The homepage lists a "free value checker" and a "free domain appraisal." Run your name through it before you pick a price.
  • Afternic's sell page (afternic.com/sell-domains). It says it's free to join, and it has a commission calculator for Buy it Now sales. More on those numbers below.

That is the whole list. Two tools, both checked today. Other marketplaces I tried to read returned a 403 or a 404, so I am not quoting their fees.

Pick your price before you pick a marketplace

A buyer looking at a name sees one thing: is this worth the number on the screen?

  • Run an appraisal first. It is a guide, not a promise.
  • Price for the buyer you expect. A side project founder does not pay like a funded company.
  • Fixed price beats "make offer" for small names. Buyers skip anything that starts a negotiation.

What the commission actually does to your payout

Afternic's live page is the clearest one I could read. Here is what it states for Buy it Now:

Plan Standard rate Reduced rate (nameservers on GoDaddy Aftermarket)
Afternic Boost 30% 20%
Afternic Basic 25% 15%

The page also says "There is a $15 minimum commission fee with all sales."

Do the math on a cheap name. A $40 sale at 25% would be $10, but the $15 minimum applies, so you pay $15. That is more than a third of the sale.

Small names and percentage fees do not mix well. Check the minimum, not just the rate.

Note the catch: the lower rate depends on pointing your domain at their nameservers. That is a trade. More reach, less control of where the name resolves.

What buyers look for

Buyers are scared of getting scammed. Make it easy for them to trust you.

  • Proof you own it. DNS verification is the cleanest way.
  • A clear transfer promise. How long, and what happens if it fails.
  • A safe way to pay. Card checkout beats wiring money to a stranger.

I built 199.domains around exactly those three. The homepage says every listing passes an AI quality review and owner verification through DNS before it goes live. Buyers pay by card through Stripe with guest checkout, no account. The seller starts the registrar transfer within 72 hours, and the buyer gets a full refund, fee included, if the domain is not transferred.

Prices run from $29 to $199, so it is $199 or less for every name. No auctions, no offers.

An honest admission: that ceiling is a real limit. If your name is worth $5,000, a fixed-price marketplace under $200 is the wrong place for it. It is built for the brandable and keyword names that sit unsold in a lot of portfolios.

A first-week plan

  1. Pick your three best names.
  2. Appraise each one.
  3. Decide which are under $200 and which are not.
  4. List the cheap ones where verification and refunds are built in.
  5. Keep the expensive ones for a place with a negotiation process.

Where I would start

If you have names that are priced to move, put them on 199.domains this week. The marketplace is open to public submissions. Start with the one name you would be happiest to sell.

One small ask

Tell me in the comments what you do when a buyer asks for a discount. Do you hold the price, or do you move?

I run the Vibe Coding is Life community. Come say hi in the Facebook group or the free Skool community.

Top comments (0)