When our team hit 20 employees, payroll became a project. We were spending four hours every two weeks on manual reconciliation. The shortlist came down to Gusto, Rippling, and OnPay — and the decision wasn't obvious.
What We Were Actually Solving For
The spreadsheet method was failing because of three things: tax filing in two states, contractor vs W-2 classification complexity, and benefits administration that lived in a separate system.
Any platform we chose needed to handle multi-state payroll, automated tax filings, and at least basic benefits without requiring us to manage three different systems.
Gusto
Gusto's onboarding is the fastest I've seen for a team our size. The UI is built for non-HR people, which mattered because our "HR department" was also our office manager.
The limitation: Gusto starts feeling expensive when you layer in benefits administration. The Plus plan, which includes most of the compliance features you actually need beyond 15 employees, runs meaningfully more per seat than the base tier suggests.
Rippling
Rippling is the right answer if you want a unified system. Payroll, IT, HR, and device management in one platform. The integration story is strong.
It's also complex to set up. For a 25-person team without dedicated IT, Rippling's power becomes overhead. You're buying a platform designed for teams that will grow into it.
OnPay
OnPay was the one I didn't expect to like as much as I did. Flat pricing, no per-feature upsells, and tax filing handling that worked without babysitting.
We covered the full evaluation in more detail at hrpaypick.com/best-payroll-software-small-business/ — including a breakdown of which platforms work best at different team size thresholds.
For contractors and hybrid teams, the W-2/1099 handling matters more than it looks on a feature checklist. OnPay got this right in a way the others didn't quite match at our price point.
How We Decided
The decision framework we used:
- What's the all-in per-seat cost at 30 seats? (not the advertised rate)
- Which states do we file in, and how is that handled?
- Who actually runs payroll — HR professional or operational generalist?
- What's the support model when something breaks on a pay cycle?
That fourth question eliminated one option entirely after we tested the support queue.
The payroll software market has gotten crowded enough that there's no universally wrong answer at the SMB level — but there are wrong answers for specific team profiles. The comparison that helped us most is at hrpaypick.com/onpay-review/.
Top comments (0)