Why won't my forEach lambda allow me to exit my function with a return statement in Java?

Let’s say you have a basket of food:

List<Food> basket = List.of(
     new Food("Apple", FRUIT),
     new Food("Banana", FRUIT),
     new Food("Carrot", VEGETABLE),
     new Food("Orange", FRUIT),
);

And a requirement to only accept this basket if it is only filled with fruits. To meet this requirement, you decide to implement a for loop:

private boolean containtsOnlyFruits(List<Food> basket) {
for (Food food : basket) {
        if (food.getFoodType() != FRUIT) {
            return false;
        }
    }
    return true;
}

Then, you remember you’ve been learning about Java Lambdas and a more functional approach, so you decide to write the same thing in a forEach lambda:

private boolean containtsOnlyFruits(List<Food> basket) {
    basket.forEach(food -> {
        if (food.getFoodType() != FRUIT) {
            return false;
        }
    });
    return true;
}

Just to come across an error:

unexpected return value

Why is that?

A lambda is nothing more than a function. In this case, an anonymous function, or in other words, a function without a name. Just like any other function, a lambda can receive arguments and also expect something to be returned.

When you try to return false from the forEach lambda, you’re actually trying to exit this anonymous function and output a boolean. However, the forEach function is not expected to return any result. This is simply not how this function is implemented.

In fact, if you look at the implementation of the forEach function, you will see that it accepts a Consumer:

default void forEach(Consumer<? super T> action) {
    Objects.requireNonNull(action);
    for (T t : this) {
        action.accept(t);
    }
}

A Consumer is an interface that represents an operation that accepts a single input argument and returns no result. In this implementation, you can see that under the hood, the forEach function is using a for each loop, performing the given action and not returning anything.

So to satisfy our operation in a functional approach, we will need to find another lambda. There is a good candidates here: allMatch.

With the allMatch lambda, we can check if all of the elements of the basket is a fruit:

private boolean onlyFruits(List<Food> basket) {
    return basket.stream().allMatch(food -> food.getFoodType() == FRUIT);
}

If that’s the case, our lambda will return true. And if we look at the internal of allMatch:

boolean allMatch(Predicate<? super T> predicate);

We will see that the allMatch function expects a Predicate.

A Predicate is a functional interface just like a Consumer, but it works a bit differently. While a Consumer represents an operation that accepts a single input argument and returns no result, a Predicate represents a predicate (boolean-valued function) of one argument that is used to test an object for a condition and return a boolean value (true or false).

There are other very important functional interfaces. Can you tell me what they are and how they work?

Stay curious!

Contribute

Writing takes time and effort. I love writing and sharing knowledge, but I also have bills to pay.

If you like my work, please consider donating through Buy Me a Coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/RaphaelDeLio

Or by sending me BitCoin: 1HjG7pmghg3Z8RATH4aiUWr156BGafJ6Zw

Comments

[Viktor]

Why won't my forEach lambda allow me to exit my function with a return statement in Java?

Because forEach take a Consumer, and don`t return anything.

There are other very important functional interfaces. Can you tell me what they are and how they work?

How deep do you want understand it? If you request is serious interesting you, take a guide or article, but it`s not in one pages and not for studying from comment here.

[Raphael De Lio]

Couldn't be more simple than that! 🙌