You can play the whole song
along with the record.
Every change lands.
The fills fall into place.
The ending arrives
exactly when it should.
Then you play it at rehearsal,
with the drummer counting in
and no record,
and somewhere in the second verse
you are a bar ahead of everybody
and not sure how you got there.
The record was doing more
than you knew.
It was keeping time for you.
You heard the snare
and your hand moved.
It was telling you
where the changes were.
The singer's breath before the chorus
was your cue,
and you never learned the cue,
only the reaction to it.
It was covering for you.
A missed note under a full band
on a mastered recording
vanishes completely,
so you never heard yourself miss it.
And it never waited
and never rushed,
so you never had to decide
where the beat was.
That decision is the job.
Playing with the record
teaches you to follow.
Playing in a band
asks you to hold.
They feel identical in your hands,
and they are different skills.
So use the record,
and then take it away
in stages.
Turn it down
until you can barely hear it,
and notice where you start to drift.
Pull the fader right down
for eight bars
and bring it back,
and listen for whether you come in
on the beat
or a little either side of it.
Play with a click only,
and count the form out loud,
verse, verse, chorus, verse,
so the map of the song
lives in your head
and not in the singer's voice.
Then record yourself alone,
and play the record
straight after.
The gap between the two
is the part of the song
you have not learned yet.
It is usually smaller than you fear,
and it sits in exactly the places
where the record was carrying you.
Learn those places on purpose.
The band will not have
the singer from the album.
It will have you,
and whatever you can hold
when nothing is holding it for you.
– Serguey Asael Shinder
Top comments (0)