Web scraping in 2026 means dealing with sophisticated anti-bot systems, geo-restrictions, and CAPTCHAs on nearly every major site. Your scraper is only as good as your proxy infrastructure.
I've tested six of the most popular proxy services over the past three months across real scraping workloads — e-commerce, job boards, social media, and search engines. Here's what I found.
Quick Comparison Table
| Provider | Residential IPs | Price/GB | Free Trial | Anti-Bot Bypass | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bright Data | 72M+ | $8.40/GB | $5 credit | Built-in | Enterprise, large scale |
| Oxylabs | 100M+ | $8/GB | 7-day trial | Built-in | Geo-targeting, SERP |
| Smartproxy | 55M+ | $7/GB | 3-day trial | Add-on | Mid-range budgets |
| ScraperAPI | 40M+ | ~$2.50/1K requests | 5K free | Built-in | Managed scraping |
| ScrapeOps | Aggregated | ~$3/1K requests | 1K free | Multi-provider | Proxy rotation |
| ThorData | 60M+ | $3/GB | Trial available | Basic | Budget residential |
Residential vs Datacenter vs Mobile Proxies
Datacenter proxies are cheap ($0.50-$2/GB) and fast, but most major sites detect and block them instantly in 2026. Use them only for sites without anti-bot protection.
Residential proxies route through real ISP connections. They're 5-10x more expensive but dramatically harder to detect. This is the baseline for scraping Amazon, Google, LinkedIn, or any protected target.
Mobile proxies use cellular IPs and are nearly undetectable. They're also the most expensive ($15-$30/GB). Use them only when residential fails — typically for social media platforms like Instagram or TikTok.
The Six Services, Ranked
1. ScraperAPI — Best Managed Solution
ScraperAPI takes a different approach: instead of giving you raw proxies, you send your target URL to their API and they handle proxy rotation, retries, CAPTCHA solving, and browser rendering automatically.
Why it wins for most scrapers: You don't manage proxy pools. Their API handles the complexity. It's particularly strong for structured data extraction — pass a URL, get clean HTML or JSON back.
- 5,000 free API credits to test
- Automatic retries and IP rotation
- Built-in CAPTCHA and JS rendering
- Simple REST API — one line of code
Best for: Developers who want results without managing infrastructure. If you're building a scraper and want to focus on parsing, not proxy management, start here.
2. ScrapeOps — Best Proxy Aggregator
ScrapeOps doesn't provide its own proxies. Instead, it aggregates multiple proxy providers and routes your requests through whichever performs best for your target site.
Why this is underrated: When Bright Data gets blocked on a site, ScrapeOps automatically falls back to another provider. You get multi-provider redundancy through a single API.
- Aggregates 20+ proxy providers
- Smart routing based on target domain
- Real-time success rate monitoring
- 1,000 free API credits
Best for: Teams scraping diverse targets. Instead of committing to one provider, ScrapeOps lets you benefit from all of them.
3. Bright Data — Best for Enterprise Scale
The 800-pound gorilla. Bright Data has the largest proxy network (72M+ residential IPs) and the most features: Web Unlocker, SERP API, Browser API, and pre-built dataset marketplace.
The catch: It's expensive, the dashboard is complex, and pricing is opaque. You'll need to talk to sales for serious volume.
- Largest IP pool in the industry
- Web Unlocker handles any anti-bot system
- Pre-built datasets available for purchase
- Compliance-certified (SOC 2, GDPR)
Best for: Companies with dedicated scraping teams and budget. Overkill for indie developers.
4. Oxylabs — Best for Geo-Targeting
Oxylabs matches Bright Data in scale (100M+ IPs) and excels at geo-targeting with city-level precision. Their SERP scraping API is arguably the best in the market.
- 100M+ residential IPs across 195 countries
- City-level targeting precision
- Excellent SERP API
- 7-day free trial
Best for: SERP monitoring and location-specific scraping. If you need search results from specific cities, Oxylabs delivers.
5. ThorData — Best Budget Residential
ThorData offers residential proxies at roughly a third of Bright Data's price. The pool is smaller and the tooling is simpler, but for straightforward residential proxy needs, the value is hard to beat.
- 60M+ residential IPs
- $3/GB — significantly cheaper than competitors
- Simple API, standard proxy format
- Trial credits available
Best for: Budget-conscious scrapers who need residential IPs without enterprise features. Excellent price-to-performance ratio for standard web scraping.
6. Smartproxy — Solid Mid-Range
Smartproxy sits between budget options and enterprise tools. Good residential pool, reasonable pricing, and a clean dashboard. No major standout feature, but no major weakness either.
- 55M+ residential IPs
- Clean, intuitive dashboard
- Good documentation
- 3-day free trial
Best for: Teams that need more than budget providers but don't need enterprise complexity.
My Recommendation
For most developers reading this, here's the decision tree:
- Just starting out? Use ScraperAPI. The managed approach means you write less code and get results faster.
- Scraping many different sites? Use ScrapeOps to let smart routing handle provider selection.
- Need cheap residential IPs? ThorData gives you the best GB rate.
- Enterprise scale? Bright Data or Oxylabs, depending on whether you need geo-targeting.
Don't overthink it. Grab a free trial, test against your actual target sites, and measure success rates. The "best" proxy is the one that works for your specific use case.
What proxy service are you using in 2026? Share your experience in the comments.
Top comments (0)