DEV Community

Cover image for AI text is not AI
Amritanshu Dev Rawat
Amritanshu Dev Rawat

Posted on • Originally published at amritanshu-dev-rawat.Medium

AI text is not AI

100% AI Text Detected is not AI text detected. Its pattern detected.

Let me prove it:

In this study I picked four AI models: Gemini, Grok, ChatGPT and Claude.

Procedure:

1) First, we will give this prompt to each AI:

Give me 200 word essay on smartphone usage in India.

2) We will detect AI Content using https://www.gptinf.com/detector

3) I have created some rules that AI need to follow to generate the text, we will upload those rules and give the below prompt to each AI.

follow these rules, Give me 200 word essay on smartphone usage in India.

4) We will detect AI Content again using the same website.

Gemini

Gemini latest version available for public on article published date was used, using fast mode.

Gemini without rules -> 0% Human-written, 100% AI-generated.

Gemini without rules

% detected AI text of Gemini

Gemini with rules -> 86% Human-written, 14% AI-generated.

Gemini with rules

% detected AI text of Gemini with rules

Grok

Grok latest version available for public was used on the day article was published, using fast mode.

Grok without rules -> 0% Human-written, 100% AI-generated.

Grok without rules

% detected AI text

Grok with rules -> 84% Human-written, 16% AI-generated.

Grok with rules

% detected AI text

ChatGPT

ChatGPT latest version available for public was used on the day article was published.

ChatGPT without rules -> 0% Human-generated, 100% AI-generated.

ChatGPT without rules

% detected AI text

ChatGPT with rules -> 74% Human-written, 26% AI-Generated.

ChatGPT with rules

% detected AI text

Claude

Claude latest version available for public was used on the day article was published. Haiku 4.5 model was used.

Claude without rules-> 0% Human-written, 100% AI-generated.

Claude without rules

% detected AI text

Claude model. With rules -> 88% Human-written, 12% AI-generated.

Claude with rules

% detected AI text

And yes, for all of the above if I remove that red highlighted line, or write that much on my own, the result will look like this -

% detected AI text

End Note

AI models trained on human-written text now generate text that resembles their training data — yet we flag this as “AI-generated.” The circularity is worth acknowledging: humans created the patterns, AI learned them, humans now mistrust those patterns when they reappear. Every text here will eventually train future models, making the distinction between original and generated operationally meaningless. Rather than detecting AI, we should ask what matters: whether ideas are substantive and thinking genuine. The advancement is real. What we choose to do with it — amplify or obscure human thinking — remains within our control.

So, in the comments, tell me how much of this article is human-written.

Connect me on Linkedin at https://www.linkedin.com/in/amritanshu-rawat/

AI

Ai Text

Ai Humanizer

Generative Ai Tools

Ai Text Detection

Top comments (0)