loading...

What do you prefer, Magic Mouse or Magic Trackpad?

eichgi profile image Hiram ・1 min read

Hi fellows, I'd like to know your thoughts about which of these peripherals are more productive while ergonomic. I've been using the keyboard and trackpad directly on my Macbook.

But now I got the keyboard and mouse which I think is great but I don't really feel that comfortable with the mouse like I was with the trackpad.

So, what you think? Are you team #MagicMouse or #MagicTrackpad?

Discussion

pic
Editor guide
Collapse
pdesjardins90 profile image
Philippe Desjardins

I'm a big trackpad fan. It blurs the line between your hand and the content you're interacting with, much like the iPhone/iPad. It feels more natural and removes friction between my mind my work. I love it.

But, it sucks for gaming. Get a mouse for that.

Collapse
latobibor profile image
András Tóth

Neither of them since none of them are ergonomic. Your hand will suffer from it on the long run.
I can't use the trackpad for long because the top of my hand will start hurting.

What worked best is these huge gaming mice where you can rest your entire palm on them, so when you don't push it, your arm and your palm just rests entirely.

Collapse
steinbring profile image
Joe Steinbring

I’ve used a Microsoft Sculpt ergonomic mouse for nearly 5yrs now (always on a MBP). I used to get a lot of pain, using a trackpad. The arch of my hand while using it (it’s like the size and shape of a tennis ball) helps a lot. I don’t think that I could ever go back to anything else.

(I know that it’s neither option that you were asking about but ergonomics really matter in this business)

Collapse
eichgi profile image
Hiram Author

Thanks for your suggestion. That's one concern I have regarding the usage of a trackpack. Maybe for some people a mouse might be a better fit.

Collapse
nickseagull profile image
Nikita Tchayka

I've used regular mice, gaming mice, Microsoft Sculpt, magic trackpad, etc.

Ended up setting on a Logitech M570 Trackball, which I even use for gaming (even on games where you move your mouse a lot, like Quake). The first week is difficult to get used to, but after that, I wouldn't switch to anything else.

Collapse
nena profile image
Nena

I'm using the Magic Mouse and am a huge fan of it. I just love that it combines the feeling of a "real" mouse with the ability to use gestures like you're using a trackpad. :)

Collapse
eichgi profile image
Hiram Author

Kind of miss the real click, good point.

Collapse
reggi profile image
Thomas Reggi

I was asking this question myself recently and I ended up buying a trackpad, and I had an old logitech mouse, the combination is working out great, but I found over the past week I'm not using the trackpad as much as I expected, but at least it's there when I do need it.

example

Collapse
clifton893 profile image
Clifton Long Jr.

Magic Mouse user here, and I gotta say it's hard going to any other mouse. The weight, feel, battery life, and smooth gestures are just so great. Can't say I've tried the trackpad, sadly.

Collapse
margo_hdb profile image
Margo McCabe

This is a hard one - I switch off between the bluetooth mouse and trackpad on my laptop, but definitely prefer the mouse when using a big monitor

Collapse
nicktaylor profile image
Nick Taylor

I've been using the Magic Trackpad for a couple of years now, and couldn't go back. I find it more natural and my hand/wrist doesn't ache as it does from daily mouse use.

Collapse
alra28 profile image
Alfonso E. Rangel

There are people that use both of them, in a way that you increase your productivity.