Somewhere right now a guy at a bar is making a stranger sign an NDA on a napkin. For an app idea. Just sit with that.
That napkin is going in a drawer. The drawer is a graveyard. Quick tour.
Exhibit A: bro we should open a bar
Two beers in, you're suddenly a hospitality mogul. Picking a name. Arguing about taco night. By the time the check comes, the bar is already dead. It died of "let's talk about this again soon," which never happens.
Exhibit B: bro we should start a band
A guitar shows up at a party. Someone says "we should actually start something." One rehearsal happens. In a garage. A neighbor complains. The band dies before it has a name or a single original song. RIP.
Exhibit C: the app idea, may it rest in your Notes app
The big one. Open your Notes app, it's a cemetery. "App that reminds you to text people back." Dead. "Tinder but for gym buddies." Dead. These ideas didn't fail. They never even got born.
Why none of these make it out alive
The ideas aren't even bad. Some are genuinely good. The problem is ideas are free and easy to say out loud. Building one makes it real, and real things can fail in public with your name on them.
Saying "we should open a bar" costs nothing. Actually opening one costs $400,000, a liquor license, and every Saturday for five years. Guess which one people actually do.
Building also got way easier, which makes this worse. You don't need a technical cofounder anymore. You can describe an app to a chat box and watch a prototype show up before your coffee's cold. The wall that used to stop people is mostly gone. People are still standing where it used to be, out of habit.
A small ceremony for the ones we lost
HERE LIES:
"the app idea I had in the shower"
born: tuesday
died: tuesday, when I got out of the shower
HERE LIES:
"our band"
born: one guitar, one party
died: one noise complaint
HERE LIES:
"the bar we were gonna open"
born: 1:47am
died: 1:48am, checked the bill
Two graves that still have a heartbeat
Here's the part nobody tells you. Sometimes the dumb weekend version doesn't fully die. You bury it, forget about it, then months later check your phone and it's quietly paying for dinner.
App one. Built it in a weekend, haven't touched it since. Checked it last week out of guilt. Last 7 days alone: $290 and 969 new users, 81% hitting the paywall. I did nothing to earn that. It just sits there collecting money like a vending machine that never runs out.
App two. The saddest, sweetest zombie. 211 total users since launch ever, said quietly. Look at the revenue chart though.
Flat line at $9.99 for months. One subscriber, renewing forever. Like one guy still showing up to the band's old practice garage, sitting in a folding chair, waiting for a reunion that already happened without him.
That one subscriber has paid more than I've thought about this app in three months. I don't know who they are. I will never ask. Asking might break it.
Neither app is good or finished. Neither has a roadmap. Both still make real money every week, completely unsupervised, while my actually clever unbuilt ideas sit in Notes earning nothing.
Dead apps making lunch money beat brilliant ideas making nothing. Every time.
The one guy who didn't die with his idea
Someone had basically my exact app idea. Instead of journaling about it, he built it in a weekend and shipped it. Got 200 users. Moved on with his life. I was still picking a font. Same idea, he just did it.
That's the whole secret. Stop guarding the napkin. Build the ugly version this weekend, before it joins the bar and the band in the graveyard.
Top comments (0)