DEV Community

Cover image for No Peaceful Ruleset? What Simulations Can't Imagine
Ingo Steinke, web developer
Ingo Steinke, web developer Subscriber Community Curator

Posted on Edited on AI-assisted

No Peaceful Ruleset? What Simulations Can't Imagine

Disclaimer:

This series of articles, unlike most of my other publications, was largely written and edited by AI, and so are the images. I have edited and removed some slop later, making this series even more erratic and eclectic. I hope you enjoy it nevertheless.

Upcoming articles will be totally(*) hand-written again.

(*) up to 99%

Why Can't There Be Peace?

One of the most overlooked modifications of most civilization games is the lack of a consistently peaceful game. Not only is it hard to achieve, if at all, but it doesn't seem to be in high demand, either. You can still do that with only human players that agree and stick to the idea without forgetting their peaceful intentions later.

I don't know if it's a problem of Civilization and freeciv specifically, or with the game industry's clichés, or a lack of utopian vision in human nature or society? Those who experienced famine and poverty, taught us a "never enough" mindset", and in most games, there is always some kind of friction. Minecraft is a notable exception that became very popular despite or because of the lack of the classic "you always have some mission to achieve, and please adhere to the rules of the game."

The Limits of Simulation

I mentioned the "unknown unknowns". Is it truly impossible to achieve a truly peaceful and sustainable society, at least within the constraints of a game server like Civilization, FreeCiv, or SimCity, and why?

Simulation games combine utopian and dystopian aspects. A sophisticated player could strive to dominate the game as a benevolent dictator, balancing freedom and happiness with strict constraints and invincible economic and military power. History has seen similar rulers praised for periods of stability, trade, and progress, albeit often followed by periods of rivalry and disruption.

What we can learn from simulation games: Resources aren't inifinite. Neglecting ecology and social sustainability doesn't pay of economically, not mid-term, and surely not when you run out of ore and coal to sell to others. Priorities and compromise are necessary. We can still have fun.

But what can we find beyond the obvious?

what is it

The monolith would be a fitting metaphor. In Arthur C. Clarke's and Stanley Kubrick's vision, it appears as an object that cannot be understood from within the cognitive framework of those who encounter it. It does not merely represent a new technology on the tech tree. It represents an entirely different tech tree or philosophy.

Willing to Change the Rules

Now, open-source games that even come with a text-based editor allow us to modify not only the map, but also the rules! What a promising spark of inspiration! And how disappointing to discover that there are rules below the rules. Of course there are always some kinds of contraints and some kind of friction.

Peaceful ruleset discussion screenshot

"I've never played the original civilization game. After installing Linux [...] I disovered [freeciv] [...] based on the classic civ2-style freeciv ruleset. Not reinventing the wheel, I'd be glad to install a peaceful ruleset ..."

In an old forum post dating back to 2009, Peaceful ruleset for freeciv, my younger self suggested a peaceful ruleset and described what was impossible using the offline scenario editor plus editing the ruleset files on their local computer. A related recent discussion in the freeciv forum mused on how not building a defensive army makes you depend on your neighbor's behavior. Playing peacefully in a solo game without barbarians without crashing the server might be possible with recent software versions, but that's not the point. Quoting my 2009 post:

the AI computer players will find a way to establish attacking units no matter what. I tried to set attack=0 for all units, but the AI got attack points from barracks and veteran system

Note that "AI", back then, just meant an autonomous player character controlled by the computer.

Civilization simulation scenario with two countries competing with pirates

This is a simulation scenario illustration based on an original screenshot of a freeciv web session with two AI civilizations and random barbarians against a single human player getting caught into a foreseeable narrow-minded gameplay forcing them to focus on military build-up and defence spending, neglecting what we could only imagine building with a similar game engine.

Peace isn't Boring

I thought it must be self-evident that a peaceful world is not boring. There can still be competition, and there can be creativity for sure.

  • there are aspects besides military strength that can be used to still have interesting and different units: firepower (== working power for workers and engineers as well), range of vision, speed of movement, special flags and roles like Diplomat, SuperSpy, IgZOC (ignore Zone of Control), IgTer (ignore terrain) etc
  • aspects for civil research, trade, flight, diplomacy that were neglected in classical military gameplay - change the rules to emphasize these aspects ...

The biggest issue with those kinds of changes were that too unexpected changes made the engine crash eventually. There were implicit requirements and assumptions, thus invisible limits, of how substantially a ruleset is allowed to change.

As disussed as Dystopian Civilization Scenarios in part two of this series, SimCity and Lincity focus on peaceful economic simulation, while the reality they illustrate might have just moved violence and exploitation out of sight. Yet, there is still friction, even if only the so-called first-world problems.

Boring Lincity Mod Ideas based on other Games

And there are a multitude of other games, many of whom focus on building, architecture, interior design, or railway nostalgia.

City simulation screenshot with port, railways and road junction bridges

Some obvious ideas to add to a game were maybe just too obvious while too boring to implement: Airports, subway train lines and subterranean electricity would add complexity but no essentially new concepts. Lincity could have borrowed some of Freeciv's features, like alternative architecture and wonders of the world. Similar to monuments and rocket launch pads, world wonders would take time and resources to build. Once finished, they could look spectacular and add a possibility or modification factor: A lighthouse improves oversea trade. A central station boosts all train lines. A telescope benefits science, while the Great Library unlocks scientific progress without further effort.

Image adding clichéd mod ideas to an original Lincity screenshot

Finally, we could bring back the original SimCity's catastrophic threats of flood, earthquake, and a giant Godzilla monster. And a foreign army could attack our peaceful city, adding to the Lincity my most disliked core aspect of Freeciv.

Simulating Future as an Extension of Our Past

War is always possible in Freeciv. An era of mining, burning and world trade seems practically inevitable before achieving recycling and solar power. And when a postmodern society runs out of forests, you can still build classic town houses that always look the same. As a pragmatic idea to change gameplay, why not randomly mix up the technology tree and required tech levels, or add one surprise achievement?

Most strategy and simulation games are built around the assumption that the future is an extension of the past and present, with eventual disruptions. New discoveries unlock predictable branches of development. Bronze leads to iron. Steam leads to electricity. Literacy leads to democracy. The player is invited to optimize, accelerate, and prioritize, but rarely to question the structure itself.

Imaginary historical airport and coal harbor in a lincity-ng-screenshot modified by AI in 2026

To illustrate the divergency and diversity of utopias and ideas about progress, I let AI add an airport and a local coal harbor to my imaginary city. A historic one, with vintage planes, balloons, and Zeppelin aircraft. At that time, many conservatives opposed trains, airplane and modern architecture. A century later, conservatives hold on to an ideal of linear technological progress, while alternatives question that idea. As much as smoking chimneys once stood for progress and prosperity, both the fossil industry and its renewable alternatives fuel heated conflicts about where the world could and should be heading to avoid disaster and falling back into chaos and poverty.

Post-Industrial Divergence

Some of the singular disruptions and obseletions in gameplay tech trees mirror post-industrial restructuring where former ore mines and trash pits turn into artificial lakes and hills used for leisure and recreation. Former factories turned into art studios and techno music clubs, and the former airport at Tempelhofer Feld in Berlin is now one of the world's largest undeveloped inner-city real estate.

Imaginary former airfield and lake used for leisure in a lincity-ng-screenshot modified by AI

Imaginary former airfield and lake used for leisure in a lincity-ng-screenshot modified by AI, inspired by Tempelhofer Feld airfield in Berlin, Germany.

In the virtual city simulation games, those areas are still just unused and unusable lots in top locations. This lack of innovation reveals a deeper limitation of simulation. A game can model uncertainty, but only uncertainty anticipated by its designers. Every possible future already exists somewhere in the code, waiting to be unlocked. Even random events are predefined categories selected from a finite set of possibilities. The truly unknown cannot appear because it has never been encoded.

Unimaginative Repetitive History

Much like the way a local history museum might recreate scenes from the Stone Age or the early Middle Ages, I — again with the help of AI — had an early-stage game scenario reconstructed that brings together numerous clichés typical of such games. The original image featured in the mentioned article got lost while editing.

Medieval city time-travel simulation

Starting from this psuedo-medieval time-travel illustration, how would such a scenario evolve within the rules of a game? Could we still claim that peace isn't boring? And which parts of our real history were, once again, banished from sight and erased from the history books?

Solarpunk futurist scenario based on an older lincity-ng screenshot

1256 years later, still the same (tourist?) horse carriage in front of the same university, the same containers at the port, and still exactly 12.9% garbage (afval): Based on the fictitious year 670 scenario shown in the previous article, this implausible AI image perfectly illustrates machine's lack of imagination and out-of-context information.

Fair enough, a historic city center that looks slightly out of time isn't implausible after all. European capitals like Paris, London, and Berlin preserved their historic landmarks and built more modern extensions around it. The following image is yet another fake, but close to what can be seen in later stages of a game.

Imaginary isometric city builder simulation with a historic village center surrounded by a modern perimeter.

The image depicts an isometric city builder simulation featuring a preserved historic core surrounded by modern urban expansion. A multi-lane beltway ring-road loops around the central river area, high-rises, and industrial sites. Surrounding the outer perimeter are contemporary developments, including factories, commercial strip malls, fast-food outlets, and extensive parking lots.

Surreal Hodgepodge Aesthetics

Another apsect is the AI's unquestioning acceptance of false assumptions. Like in a mixed toy collection assembled by a little child, the scale of the buildings and figures did not match in the original image and in the simple graphics of the game it was inspired by: gigantic windmills overshadowing the historical university campus, a larger than life factory next to a small modern port with miniature oversea containers, all crammed together in a village center that is rather a symbolic data visualization than a realistic city simulation.

Computer graphics of symbolized humans and buildings which don't match realistically in size and scale

That's part of the fun, however.

Unforeseen Glitches

Enter the glitch: some classic games weren't remembered for their original intent alone, but for accidental features and glitches that added surprise, chaos, and creativity.

As with LLM-based AI, we're trying to contain the chaos and undesirable side effects of a system that already feels out of control. While it's still too restricted and predictable in some ways, it's already going beyond what we, as human designers, can foresee.

Columbus never found the route to India he was looking for. What he started instead was a permanent exchange of plants, animals, people, and disease across two hemispheres, and the genocide, empires, and global capitalism that followed from it.

Errors of Mass Destruction

Ironically, colonization wasn't only unintended; it might have been unnecessary after all, even though it might have stabilized Europe's economic situation. By the time Christopher Columbus initiated the Columbian Exchange in 1492, the foundational shifts of the Early Renaissance, led by figures like Dante, Petrarch, Giotto, and Brunelleschi, had already taken place, and society had recovered from the Medieval setback caused by pandemics and bad harvest.

Pseudo-screenshot of a computer game scene showing medieval crusade ships somehow connected to the historic Battle of Aachen

Had economic systems not relied on the perpetual expansion of territory and forced labor, alternative structural incentives might have driven technical development much earlier. Historians like Moses Finley have frequently noted that classical societies possessed the foundational scientific concepts necessary for industrialization. The Roman Empire might have dicovered magnetism and electricity and made achieved an industrial revolution if not slave labor and looting foreign countries had been such a cheap alternative.

The Ashes of Alexandria's Library and the Oil Fields of Arabia Rewriting Human History

The counterfactual is that changing certain events in the Middle Ages might have altered the entire course of technological development: preserving the Library of Alexandria, for instance, could have accelerated scientific progress centuries before Columbus, potentially making European colonial expansion less economically or technologically necessary. Conversely, the discovery of Saudi Arabia's oil reserves centuries earlier might have shifted the balance of global economic power long before the Industrial Revolution. History, in this sense, is not simply a sequence of inevitable technological breakthroughs, but a fragile chain of events in which the preservation, transmission, and financing of knowledge can matter as much as its discovery.

Orientalist version of the earlier pseudo-screenshots

In the Civilization series, this historical trajectory is explicitly mechanized through the interaction of the Tech Tree, Great People, and Cultural Wonders. A civilization can lead the world in cultural and scientific advancement — much like the Islamic Golden Age — but if its infrastructure is pillaged by external invasions (such as barbarian hordes, crusaders, or rival military empires) or if it lacks the economic capital to fund universities and labs, its technological lead evaporates.

When the Technology Tree fails to fit

A civilization game can simulate the invention of gunpowder because the designers know gunpowder exists. It can add a cure for cancer and deep space travel, because scientists are currently working on it. It cannot simulate the equivalent of an invention that neither the designers nor the players can imagine.

Tech tree section from great wall and ceremonial burial to tesla coil and warp drive

Perhaps this is why every technology tree eventually feels artificial. It transforms history into a sequence of expected upgrades, while many of the most transformative shifts in human history were not upgrades at all. They changed the rules, the goals, or even the definition of progress itself.

I still like the idea of obsoletion, although it lacks accuracy. Cars might have obsoleted horseback riding. But if AI obsoletes literacy, then what will we do when we no longer have access to our commodity?

Possibility of Total Surprise

What I liked most about science fiction though, at least when I was young, is the possibility of total surprise. Deus ex machina obsoleting every expectation. A spaceship passing a black hole to apparate where no human has been before.

One might dismiss this as naive, childlike fantasy. But whether it concerns rockets, UFOs, and extraterrestrials, or ghosts, vampires, and apparitions of the Virgin Mary—such cognitive phenomena, which straddle the line between fascination and fear, optimism and superstition, are as old as humanity itself.

In a more serious and ambitious post, fellow dev blogger Mahmoud recalls, that "mysterious entities used to visit" him when he was a child, and how that connects with culture, psychology, metaphysics, and – eventually, even AI.

Although there is most probably a real, material, ontological reality underlying these experiences, how humans and machines interact with it is heavily influenced by constructivist processes: our sensory apparatus determines what we can perceive, while our mental models determine how we interpret what we perceive. In other words, we never encounter reality entirely unfiltered; we construct representations of it, shaped by biology, culture, language, prior experience, and increasingly, technology. This does not mean that reality itself is merely a social construct, but rather that our access to it is mediated by one. And that leaves room for genuine surprise: phenomena that challenge not only our expectations, but the very frameworks through which we understand the world.

Beyond the End of the Map

Real progress begins where a predicted process ends, so to say at the edge of the map, beyond the tech tree, facing questions for which there is no walkthrough, no wiki, and no prompt that can tell us what comes next.

abstract image with question marks symbolizing an unknown future

A related perspective comes from Sonia Bobrik's exploration of what life-simulation games can teach developers about building resilient systems. Her argument that simple interactions, feedback loops, and resource constraints can produce unexpected emergent behavior illustrates why complex systems so often exceed our ability to predict them. Perhaps the most interesting discoveries happen not when we follow the technology tree, but when we begin to understand the interactions it cannot anticipate.

Concluding this serious about learning lessons from gaming, games and discussion about them, much like films and literature, can also reveal a lot about our hopes and dreams, our believes, and the issues that we're currently struggling with. Even when we avoid to mention politics explicitly. Some people are already triggered by an image of modern windmill. Atomic energy promises clean air, but produces radioactive waste and risks destructive fallout. Military abuse of nuclear fission posed an even bigger threat to humanity. Many scientists and developers hope to explore and implement progress that helps humankind. However, they often risk playing someone else's game. Curiosity and creativity can be dangerous, but so is the lack thereof.

The future belongs to those who stay curious and don't rely on the fast answers that they already found.

Top comments (1)

Collapse
 
ingosteinke profile image
Ingo Steinke, web developer • • Edited

I just updated my article series, refining some thoughts, replacing some images, and removing some obvious AI slop, as that series will proably mark the peak of my experiments using generative AI in 2026.

Latest updates to Dystopian Civilization Scenarios include a new paragraph dedicated to the mines and sweatshops fuelling the wealth of "first-world" academics trying to vanguard utopia with seemingly post-industrial organic communities. Added and updated images are based on new, original Lincity screenshots, slightly altered by AI inspired by press photos of mine diggers, armored vehicles and armed overseers.

Playing games and playing around with AI will hardly change the material foundations of our world, but maybe those thought experiments can at least inspire imagination and awareness that eventually leads to real-world action. Skepticism against innovation and fear of missing out is one step out of many, and it's not "only" altruistic but for our own benefit when we question AI and what it does to our work, life, and creativity.

I already focused much more again on the principle of least AI, using it sparingly and pragmatically, mostly for coding-related research.

And I have already started to draft some new writeups which are still in the making, because I must prioritize making money, finishing customer projects, and attend a lot of events in real life this summer and autumn. If you are thrilled to read what's coming up, subscribe to my content!