DEV Community

Cover image for Dystopian Civilization Scenarios
Ingo Steinke, web developer
Ingo Steinke, web developer Subscriber Community Curator

Posted on Edited on AI-assisted

Dystopian Civilization Scenarios

Gaming, like AI, is far from what fascinates me most about technology and creative development. Still, that's what many fellow developers talk about these days, and what makes for good, controversial topics for further nerdy small talk.

This post continues the ideas from my earlier article, Learning Lessons from Gaming. As an experiment, some of the concepts below were developed in conversation with AI. Later articles, besides this series, will return to a more traditional, human-authored approach. After re-reading the mostly AI-generated draft, I have rewritten large parts of the text, replayed freeciv and lincity-ng, taking screenshots and let AI generate more specific images based on my original screenshots and ideas.

Last updated in October 2026.

Deliberately Dystopian Civilization Game Ruleset

An idea that came to my mind was a deliberately dystopian Civilization-style ruleset: a future society in which a hidden, initially inaccessible branch of the technology tree contains potential biological threats. Instead of discovering advanced technologies in ancient ruins, players might accidentally unlock viruses such as Ebola, Hantaan virus, or COVID by exploring a remote village or an abandoned research facility.

  • The Hidden Tech Tree Branch: "Biological Anomalies"
  • The Trigger: Entering a Tribal Village (Goody Hut) post-industrial era.
  • The Mutation: High-tech ruins contain preserved pre-collapse pathogens.
  • The Risk: 5% base chance per unmapped ancient ruin. The Consequences: Immediate global pandemic notification with no text, just warning symbols.

Alternatively, sarcastically, and most boringly, we could also prepare a technological box of the pandora providing unhelpful progress like AI obsoleting literacy. I can follow up on the ethics and implications of artificial intelligence. We don't need any of that at all, anyway. The last century has already brought enough inventions of mass destruction, exploiting the planet and humanity.

So, the dystopian dangers are already implied in games like Cizilivation/Freeciv and SimCity/Lincity. We would only need to alter the rules and amplify the negative aspects to shift the focus from striving for dominance, victory, luxury and an aspired effectively altruistic sustainable future technology eventually saving mankind either on this planet or colonizing planet Mars?

I wonder what could make an explicitly dystopian gameplay fail in practice. Similar to my vain attempt at coding a peaceful civ ruleset, years ago, but still either seeing veterans and pirate barbarians appear, or crashing the game server eventually.

What would break first?

The history of Civilization modding suggests that highly complex systems often fail in surprising ways. Minor code changes can have major consequences. A famous example from Civilization VI (3 lines of code in April patch that shot the AI through the head) involved only a few lines of code that dramatically altered AI priorities, leaving computer-controlled civilizations unable to pursue basic expansion and military strategies. Small assumptions embedded deep in a system can reshape the entire simulation.

The same applies to hypothetical "peaceful civilization" rule sets. You can disable wars, reduce aggression, and encourage cooperation, yet veteran barbarians still appear. Pirate raids still happen. Unexpected conflicts emerge. Sometimes the game crashes entirely, as I experienced when using the ruleset editor and a local FreeCiv server long ago. Even if current FreeCiv updates are more stable, the fundamental issue remains.

The "Peaceful Ruleset" Barbarian Paradox

Coding a peaceful ruleset while still getting veterans or aggressive pirate barbarians is a classic engine-priority conflict. Bye, bye, Utopia!

Our pseudo-hand-drawn solarpunk utopia raided by barbarians

Turning off aggressive AI parameters or checking "No Barbarians" did not always prevent the game engine bypassing a peaceful ruleset. Eventually, my frustration gave way to curiosity. The fact that the mod failed became more interesting than the original concept.

Perhaps simulations teach us most when they resist our intentions.

Impossible Sustainable Circular Economy?

SimCity offered a similar lesson. Building a resilient, circular economy based on recycling and local sustainability is possible, but considerably harder than pursuing growth through mining and trade. The game's systems reward some strategies more naturally than others because they encode assumptions about economics, infrastructure, and human behavior.

Even in a game without warfare, friction seems like a necessity.

Utopian and dystopian aspects of civilization simulation

Why is it so difficult to construct a functioning civilization simulator based solely on peaceful cooperation? Why do conflict, competition, scarcity, and disruption keep reappearing as fallback states? Is that merely a limitation of the game engine, or does it reflect assumptions inherited from the historical realities the simulation was built to represent?

Post-Colonial Real-World Dystopia, still Fuelling "First-World" Luxury Life

Civilization and construction simulation games usually start in a distant past giving you as a player the chance to strive and improve withing the limits of known history. That's hard hard enough, and it's even harder to try to rewrite history.

However, isn't it quite unlikely to think that history would repeat itself when so many decisive turns seem to have taken place by accident? Maybe that's what those games are teaching after all.

AI-generated image based on screenshots of a lincity-ng city simulation depicting historical industry, farming, a university campus, and a port importing food, luxury goods and raw material produced in the global south

SimCity taught that, while a resilient recycling economy is hard to achieve, betting on growth and international trade alone isn't sustainable either, unless you believe space travel will open up unlimited additional growth opportunities. Lincity offers trade, import and export, without caring to show what's happening beyond our small world where our wealth is accumulated. War, slavery, and famine might just happen out of sight, while we enjoy a latte in our picturesque port city university cafeteria.

Digging and Burning in the Mines and Sweatshops

Image of an industrial game scenery slightly altered to illustrate the workers living like prisoners around burning fires, junk cars, and armed guardians

Update: This is yet another game scene screenshot, built in an industrial zone in Lincity-ng and slightly altered with AI to illustrate workers living like prisoners in a polluted area overssen by armed guardians, lacking sanitary, health, and leisure, showing signs of neglect, violence, and destruction instead.

The global south, connected via freight trains and cargo shipping, is symbolized by dystopian places like "Cerro de Pasco, physically overtaken by an enormous open-pit mine" and "San Quintin, Baja California, which fuels American grocery stores" according to web search.

Bypassing ports, we can rebuild this within the limitations and rules of lincity: a remote place with mines, factories, and fosil power stations, connected by a train line to the calm and solar-power university towns with unpolluted parks, health care, and sports facilities. Following the game's logic, both places still share the same financial treasury and other global stats, including pollution and ecological balance. Much like different countries on the same planet do.

Rather than relying on individual gestures of frugality, sometimes performed with a defiant theatricality that recalls a sheltered student pretending to know what it means to work in a mine, how might we use our privileges more effectively to challenge these inequalities, given how little consumer choices and demonstrations seem to have changed so far?

The simulation cannot answer these questions, either.

Real-World Constraints Implications

Reflecting on games can teach us about the constraints of the real world their scenarios were modeled after. That raises questions extending far beyond games.

Artificial intelligence systems, like LLM-based AI, exhibit obvious constraints. They can remix existing knowledge with astonishing speed, but they remain bounded by the material they were trained on. They are exceptionally good at exploring the known space of possibilities. Exploring genuinely unknown territory might be fundamentally impossible. They didn't travel the world, and their initial perspective, just like the headquarters of many influential tech companies, is still based in the Anglo-American "western world", culture-bound and culture-blind to many aspects of life, good and bad, happening beyond what's visible in North American mainstream culture.

Unknown Unknowns

"There are unknown unknowns," a great philosopher once said. Turns out that what I would ascribe to Luhmann, Habermas, or Plato, or a thought experiment that you might think you'd learn about in Sun Tzu's War Academy, is allegedly attributed to a controversial American politician quoting a common military and NASA space agency saying, inspired by prior psychological research.

A related 2x2 grid was created in 1955 by two American psychologists, Joseph Luft and Harrington Ingham, in their development of the Johari window, a "graphic model of interpersonal behavior.

Similar wisdom has "been widely quoted since the 19th century as anonymous ancient knowledge, or alternatively attributed to authors ranging from Confucius to Bruce Lee," according to the same Wikipedia article.

Unknown unknowns

Are our tools just holding up a mirror to the limitations of human cognition and its limitations?

Note that this article, unlike most of my other publications, was mostly written and edited by AI, based on my original scribbles, and so are the images. Later articles, besides this series, will return to a more traditional, human-authored approach.

Top comments (1)

Collapse
 
ingosteinke profile image
Ingo Steinke, web developer • • Edited

I should have left you with a cliffhanger for suspense's sake. But I don't want to withhold the end of what might be a nice weekend read. Here is the sequel: Beyond the Tech Tree: What Games Can't Imagine...

I have also slightly edited both sequels to fix what the AI got wrong on second reading.