Best Practice: API in Next.js vs. Separate Backend

🔹 Next.js API Routes ("/api" Folder)

Next.js provides an "/api" folder where you can define API routes without needing a separate backend server. These API routes act like serverless functions and can handle requests just like a traditional backend.

✅ Advantages of Next.js API Routes:

1. API & UI in the same codebase – You don’t need a separate backend; everything is managed within Next.js.
2. Supports serverless functions – Works seamlessly with platforms like Vercel and Netlify for easy deployment.
3. Combines SSR and API – You can use server-side rendering (SSR) and API endpoints together.
4. Great for simple or medium-level applications – If your project doesn't require a complex backend, this is an easy solution.

❌ Disadvantages:

• Not ideal for complex backend logic like WebSockets, background tasks, or advanced authentication.
• Long-running processes (e.g., video processing, job scheduling) are difficult to handle with Next.js API Routes.

---

🔹 Separate Backend (Node.js + Express.js)

This approach involves creating a standalone Node.js + Express.js backend, which operates separately from the frontend.

✅ Advantages of a Separate Backend:

1. Highly scalable – Ideal for large-scale applications.
2. More customization – Unlike Next.js API Routes, you have full control over backend logic.
3. Better security – A dedicated backend allows for more advanced security configurations.
4. Handles background processes efficiently – Great for video processing, batch jobs, WebSockets, and complex tasks.
5. Better database management – Works well with dedicated database connections using Prisma, Mongoose, PostgreSQL, MongoDB, etc.

❌ Disadvantages:

• More complex deployment – Unlike Next.js API Routes (which can be deployed on Vercel/Netlify), a separate backend requires hosting on DigitalOcean, AWS, Heroku, etc.
• Additional maintenance required – You have to manage the backend server separately.

---

🔥 Which One is Better?

✅ For small projects or MVPs (Minimal Viable Products) → Next.js API Routes

✅ For large-scale SaaS, eCommerce, or real-time applications → Express.js + Separate Backend

If you’re building a small or medium-sized application where API logic is simple, Next.js API Routes are a great choice.

However, if you're working on a large-scale project requiring WebSockets, background tasks, video processing, or multiple services, then a separate Express.js backend is the better option.

👉 **What kind of project are you working on?