It has been a long time since I last wrote an article, and in order to break this hiatus, I decided to return to the basics and revisit core concepts that are essential for QAs and developers. I will start with the Test Pyramid, using an analogy with the ninja hierarchy in Naruto to make the concept more intuitive and relatable.
Before exploring the Test Pyramid, it is important to briefly understand what Naruto is. Naruto is a Japanese manga and anime series created by Masashi Kishimoto. The story follows Naruto Uzumaki, a young ninja from the Hidden Leaf Village who grows up lonely and socially isolated because a powerful fox spirit, the Nine-Tails, is sealed within him. Despite this, Naruto dreams of becoming the Hokage, the leader of his village, as a way to earn recognition and prove his value.
Within this universe, ninjas are classified into different levels according to their experience and responsibilities:
- Academy Students
- Genin
- Chūnin
- Jōnin
- Kage
- ANBU
But how does this hierarchy relate to the Test Pyramid? The Test Pyramid was introduced and popularized around 2009 by Mike Cohn and, in essence, it is a model used to classify automated tests with the goal of achieving better test coverage, improved software delivery performance, and, ultimately, higher software quality. The pyramid is composed of three main layers:
- Unit tests
- Integration tests
- End-to-end (E2E) tests
Let us now examine each layer of the Test Pyramid using the ninja ranks from Naruto as a metaphor.
Unit Tests = Academy Students and Genin
Academy Students are children in training who are not yet official ninjas. They learn the fundamentals, such as chakra control, village rules, teamwork, and basic jutsu like transformation, substitution, and cloning. Genin, in turn, are newly graduated ninjas who begin wearing their village headbands and performing simple missions, typically ranked D or C. They operate in teams under the supervision of a jōnin, focusing on gaining experience, discipline, and strengthening their basic skills.
In the context of software testing, unit tests closely resemble these early ninja ranks. Unit tests validate small, isolated pieces of code—such as functions or methods. Individually, they may seem simple, but when combined, they provide significant value, fast feedback, and broad test coverage. Just like Genin missions, they are numerous, lightweight, and form the foundation of the entire testing strategy.
Integration Tests = Chūnin
Chūnin are intermediate-level ninjas who demonstrate not only combat ability, but also intelligence, leadership, and emotional maturity. Usually promoted through the Chūnin Exams, they are capable of leading squads, making tactical decisions, and carrying out more complex missions ranked C or B. They represent the operational backbone of the village.
Similarly, integration tests validate the interaction between different components of a system, such as communication between services, databases, or external APIs. These tests take longer to execute than unit tests and require more setup, but they are essential for ensuring that different parts of the application work correctly together. Like Chūnin missions, there are fewer integration tests than unit tests, but they remain a critical layer of the pyramid.
End-to-End (E2E) Tests = Jōnin
Jōnin are highly experienced and versatile ninjas, capable of handling high-risk missions (rank A or S) independently and mentoring the next generation. They possess deep technical knowledge, excellent chakra control, and advanced tactical skills.
End-to-end tests align well with the Jōnin role. These tests simulate real user behavior and validate complete system flows, such as login processes or checkout journeys. While they provide high confidence, they are also more complex, slower to execute, and more expensive to maintain. For this reason, they should be used sparingly, just as Jōnin are assigned only to the most critical missions.
Manual Testing = Kage
The Kage is the most powerful and respected ninja in a village, responsible for strategic, political, and military decisions, as well as the village’s protection in times of crisis. A Kage possesses vast experience and oversees all other ranks.
In this analogy, the Kage represents manual testing. Although the Test Pyramid focuses on automation, manual testing remains essential. Without it, the entire strategy can fail. Manual tests help QAs and developers decide what should be automated, at which layer, and what is better left unautomated. They prevent low-value automation and ensure that testing efforts remain aligned with business goals.
ANBU = Non-Functional Tests
ANBU is not a traditional rank, but a special force that reports directly to the Kage. Its members perform sensitive missions such as espionage, infiltration, and protection of critical information, operating discreetly and often without recognition.
This role aligns well with non-functional tests, such as performance, load, and security testing. These tests focus on the technical qualities of a system rather than its functionality. While they may not be executed as frequently as other tests, their impact is significant, as they directly influence system stability, reliability, and trustworthiness.
Conclusion
Just as a village relies on a strong foundation of Genin, capable Chūnin, elite Jōnin, wise Kage leadership, and specialized ANBU forces, a healthy testing strategy depends on a solid base of unit tests, supported by integration tests, a small number of E2E tests, informed manual testing, and essential non-functional validations. When these elements are well balanced, teams can deliver software with confidence, quality, and sustainability.
Top comments (0)