DEV Community

Calum
Calum

Posted on • Originally published at revisepdf.com

Retrofitting Existing PDFs for Accessibility

#pdf #a11y #webdev

Retrofitting Existing PDFs for Accessibility

Many organizations face a common challenge: a large library of existing PDF documents that were created without accessibility in mind. These legacy PDFs—which may include important publications, forms, reports, and other materials—often present significant barriers to users with disabilities. Retrofitting these documents for accessibility is essential for ensuring equal access to information, meeting legal requirements, and maintaining organizational reputation.

This comprehensive guide explores strategies, techniques, and tools for efficiently retrofitting existing PDF documents to meet accessibility standards, from assessment and prioritization to specific remediation approaches for different document types.

Understanding the Retrofitting Challenge

Before diving into specific techniques, let's understand the scope of the challenge:

Common Accessibility Issues in Existing PDFs

Typical problems found in legacy documents:

  1. Structural Problems:

    • Missing or incomplete document tags
    • Improper reading order
    • Lack of heading structure
    • Untagged tables and lists
    • Inaccessible form fields

  2. Content Accessibility Issues:

    • Missing alternative text for images
    • Scanned text without OCR
    • Inaccessible charts and graphs
    • Color-dependent information
    • Poor contrast text

  3. Navigation and Usability Barriers:

    • Lack of bookmarks
    • Missing document properties
    • Undefined document language
    • Security settings blocking accessibility
    • Lack of form field labels

Retrofitting vs. Recreation

Deciding when to fix versus when to rebuild:

  1. When Retrofitting Makes Sense:

    • Document is in final form
    • Source files are unavailable
    • Content is relatively simple
    • Minor to moderate issues
    • High-value, long-lifecycle documents

  2. When Recreation May Be Better:

    • Source files are available
    • Document has extensive issues
    • Complex layouts or extensive tables
    • Scanned document with poor quality
    • Document requires substantial updates anyway

  3. Hybrid Approaches:

    • Fix critical documents immediately
    • Recreate when updates are needed
    • Prioritize based on usage and importance
    • Consider partial recreation of complex sections
    • Balance immediate needs with long-term strategy

Business Case for Retrofitting

Understanding the value proposition:

  1. Legal Risk Reduction:

    • Compliance with accessibility laws
    • Reduced litigation exposure
    • Documentation of good faith efforts
    • Proactive rather than reactive approach
    • Defense against complaints

  2. Expanded Audience Reach:

    • Access for users with disabilities
    • Improved usability for all users
    • Better mobile and device compatibility
    • Enhanced searchability and indexing
    • Improved user satisfaction

  3. Organizational Benefits:

    • Consistent information access
    • Improved document management
    • Enhanced professional reputation
    • Alignment with diversity and inclusion goals
    • Reduced support and accommodation costs

Planning Your Retrofitting Project

Strategic approaches to document remediation:

Document Inventory and Assessment

Understanding what needs to be fixed:

  1. Creating a Document Inventory:

    • Identify all public-facing PDFs
    • Catalog internal documents
    • Note document purpose and audience
    • Record document lifecycle and update frequency
    • Document location and distribution channels

  2. Accessibility Evaluation:

    • Sample testing of document types
    • Automated accessibility checking
    • Common issue identification
    • Complexity assessment
    • Remediation difficulty estimation

  3. Documentation and Reporting:

    • Record accessibility status
    • Document specific issues found
    • Estimate remediation effort
    • Create baseline measurements
    • Prepare assessment summary

Prioritization Strategy

Determining what to fix first:

  1. Risk-Based Prioritization:

    • Public-facing documents
    • High-use materials
    • Legal or compliance documents
    • Documents for essential services
    • Materials with known accessibility complaints

  2. Value-Based Assessment:

    • Usage frequency and volume
    • Document lifespan
    • Business criticality
    • User impact
    • Reputational significance

  3. Effort vs. Impact Analysis:

    • Remediation complexity
    • Resource requirements
    • Quick wins identification
    • Long-term projects planning
    • Balanced approach development

Resource Planning

Preparing for successful implementation:

  1. Skill and Knowledge Requirements:

    • PDF accessibility expertise
    • Technical remediation skills
    • Quality assurance capabilities
    • Project management experience
    • Subject matter knowledge

  2. Tools and Technology:

    • Professional remediation software
    • Online services like RevisePDF
    • Testing and verification tools
    • Project tracking systems
    • Document management integration

  3. Budget and Timeline Development:

    • Cost estimation per document type
    • Timeline development
    • Resource allocation
    • Phased implementation planning
    • ROI calculation

Retrofitting Techniques for Different Document Types

Specific approaches based on document characteristics:

Simple Text Documents

Fixing basic text-based PDFs:

  1. Common Issues:

    • Missing document tags
    • Lack of heading structure
    • Improper reading order
    • Missing alternative text
    • Basic navigation problems

  2. Remediation Approach:

    • Add document structure tags
    • Create proper heading hierarchy
    • Fix reading order
    • Add alternative text to images
    • Set document properties

  3. Tools and Methods:

    • Adobe Acrobat Pro
    • RevisePDF remediation tools
    • Basic tagging tools
    • Reading order adjustment
    • Document property setting

Complex Formatted Documents

Handling documents with sophisticated layouts:

  1. Common Issues:

    • Multi-column text
    • Sidebars and callouts
    • Complex reading order
    • Decorative elements
    • Background images and watermarks

  2. Remediation Approach:

    • Create logical reading order
    • Properly tag all content elements
    • Mark decorative elements as artifacts
    • Ensure proper content flow
    • Test with screen readers

  3. Advanced Techniques:

    • Content reordering in tag tree
    • Artifact designation
    • Reading order adjustment
    • Alternative text for meaningful graphics
    • Structure element role assignment

Forms and Interactive Documents

Making interactive content accessible:

  1. Common Issues:

    • Unlabeled form fields
    • Inaccessible buttons and controls
    • Missing instructions
    • Poor tab order
    • Lack of error identification

  2. Remediation Approach:

    • Add field labels and tooltips
    • Create logical tab order
    • Add instructions and help text
    • Ensure keyboard accessibility
    • Improve error handling

  3. Implementation Techniques:

    • Form field properties adjustment
    • Tab order setting
    • Tool tip and accessible name addition
    • Form description enhancement
    • Interactive element testing

Tables and Data-Heavy Documents

Fixing tabular information:

  1. Common Issues:

    • Untagged tables
    • Missing header cells
    • Complex merged cells
    • Tables used for layout
    • Poor table structure

  2. Remediation Approach:

    • Add proper table tags
    • Identify header cells
    • Set appropriate scope attributes
    • Fix complex table structures
    • Add table summaries when needed

  3. Advanced Table Techniques:

    • Header ID and headers attributes
    • Table summary addition
    • Caption implementation
    • Complex table restructuring
    • Table navigation testing

Scanned Documents and Images of Text

Handling documents without actual text:

  1. Common Issues:

    • No actual text content (just images)
    • Poor quality scans
    • No document structure
    • Completely inaccessible to screen readers
    • No searchable content

  2. Remediation Options:

    • OCR (Optical Character Recognition)
    • Full document recreation
    • Alternative format provision
    • Accessible summary creation
    • Hybrid approach with key content

  3. Implementation Considerations:

    • OCR quality and accuracy
    • Manual correction needs
    • Structure addition after OCR
    • Alternative format development
    • Cost-benefit analysis

Using RevisePDF for Retrofitting

Online tools for efficient remediation:

Accessibility Assessment Features

Evaluating document accessibility status:

  1. Document Analysis Tools:

    • Visit RevisePDF.com
    • Upload your PDF document
    • Use accessibility checking tools:
      • Identify missing tags and structure
      • Find missing alternative text
      • Check reading order issues
      • Verify form field accessibility
      • Detect color contrast problems

  2. Comprehensive Reporting:

    • Detailed issue identification
    • WCAG success criteria mapping
    • Issue severity classification
    • Remediation guidance
    • Compliance status summary

  3. Batch Analysis Capabilities:

    • Process multiple documents
    • Identify common issues
    • Prioritize remediation efforts
    • Track accessibility status
    • Generate summary reports

Remediation Tools

Fixing accessibility issues efficiently:

  1. Structure Enhancement:

    • Add and edit document tags
    • Create proper heading hierarchy
    • Fix reading order problems
    • Improve table accessibility
    • Enhance form field accessibility

  2. Content Accessibility Improvement:

    • Add alternative text to images
    • Fix color contrast issues
    • Improve link text
    • Add document properties
    • Create bookmarks and navigation aids

  3. Verification and Testing:

    • Check remediation effectiveness
    • Test with simulated assistive technology
    • Verify reading order
    • Confirm form field accessibility
    • Generate compliance reports

Advantages for Retrofitting Projects

Benefits of online remediation tools:

  1. Efficiency and Scalability:

    • No software installation required
    • Works on any device with a web browser
    • Batch processing capabilities
    • Consistent remediation approach
    • Accessible from any location

  2. Cost-Effectiveness:

    • Lower cost than specialized software
    • No training on complex tools
    • Reduced technical expertise requirements
    • Flexible usage based on needs
    • Scalable to project size

  3. Quality and Compliance:

    • Comprehensive accessibility checking
    • Standards-based remediation
    • Consistent quality approach
    • Documentation for compliance
    • Regular updates to match standards

Manual Remediation Techniques

Hands-on approaches for complex documents:

Using Adobe Acrobat Pro

Professional tool-based remediation:

  1. Basic Remediation Workflow:

    • Run Accessibility Checker
    • Use Make Accessible action wizard
    • Fix identified issues
    • Add tags to untagged content
    • Set document properties

  2. Advanced Techniques:

    • Manual tag tree editing
    • Reading order adjustment
    • Table editor usage
    • Form field accessibility enhancement
    • Role mapping for custom elements

  3. Quality Assurance Process:

    • Rerun accessibility checker
    • Test with screen readers
    • Verify reading order
    • Check form completion
    • Document remediation steps

Tag Tree Editing

Manual structure modification:

  1. Tag Tree Fundamentals:

    • Understanding tag types and hierarchy
    • Parent-child relationships
    • Reading order vs. tag order
    • Role assignment
    • Attribute setting

  2. Common Tag Modifications:

    • Changing tag types
    • Reordering content
    • Creating proper nesting
    • Adding missing tags
    • Fixing table structures

  3. Advanced Tag Techniques:

    • Custom tag mapping
    • Artifact designation
    • Alternative text implementation
    • Language specification
    • Complex structure creation

Reading Order Adjustment

Fixing content sequence issues:

  1. Reading Order Panel Usage:

    • Visualizing current reading sequence
    • Identifying order problems
    • Reordering content blocks
    • Handling multi-column text
    • Addressing footnotes and sidebars

  2. Common Reading Order Challenges:

    • Magazine-style layouts
    • Wrapped text around images
    • Sidebars and pull quotes
    • Tables spanning multiple pages
    • Complex form layouts

  3. Testing and Verification:

    • Screen reader testing
    • Order panel review
    • Content reflow checking
    • Logical sequence verification
    • User testing feedback

Quality Assurance and Verification

Ensuring effective remediation:

Testing Remediated Documents

Verifying accessibility improvements:

  1. Automated Retesting:

    • Run accessibility checker again
    • Compare before/after results
    • Verify all issues addressed
    • Check for new issues
    • Document improvements

  2. Screen Reader Testing:

    • Test with NVDA, JAWS, or VoiceOver
    • Verify reading order
    • Check heading navigation
    • Test table accessibility
    • Confirm form usability

  3. Comprehensive Verification:

    • Check against WCAG success criteria
    • Verify PDF/UA compliance
    • Test keyboard navigation
    • Check color contrast
    • Verify all interactive elements

Documentation and Record-Keeping

Maintaining evidence of remediation:

  1. Remediation Documentation:

    • Record issues identified
    • Document remediation steps
    • Note testing results
    • Maintain before/after comparisons
    • Create accessibility statements

  2. Compliance Evidence:

    • Save verification reports
    • Document testing methodology
    • Record standards compliance
    • Maintain remediation history
    • Create audit trail

  3. Process Improvement:

    • Identify common issues
    • Document best practices
    • Create efficiency improvements
    • Develop remediation templates
    • Share successful approaches

Ongoing Maintenance

Keeping documents accessible over time:

  1. Version Control:

    • Track document updates
    • Maintain accessibility through revisions
    • Verify changes don't create new issues
    • Document version accessibility status
    • Implement accessibility check in update workflow

  2. Periodic Retesting:

    • Schedule regular accessibility reviews
    • Check against updated standards
    • Verify continued compliance
    • Address emerging issues
    • Maintain accessibility documentation

  3. Continuous Improvement:

    • Refine remediation processes
    • Improve efficiency and quality
    • Update to new standards
    • Incorporate user feedback
    • Develop better testing methods

Scaling Retrofitting Efforts

Approaches for large document collections:

Batch Processing Strategies

Handling multiple documents efficiently:

  1. Document Classification:

    • Group similar document types
    • Identify common issues
    • Create remediation templates
    • Develop type-specific approaches
    • Prioritize within categories

  2. Automation Opportunities:

    • Identify repetitive remediation tasks
    • Use batch processing tools
    • Create remediation scripts
    • Implement partial automation
    • Focus manual effort on complex issues

  3. Using RevisePDF for Batch Remediation:

    • Upload multiple documents
    • Apply consistent fixes
    • Process similar issues across documents
    • Track batch progress
    • Generate compliance reports

Team Approaches

Organizing people for effective remediation:

  1. Team Structure Options:

    • Centralized accessibility team
    • Distributed responsibility model
    • Hybrid approach
    • Specialist and generalist roles
    • External partner integration

  2. Training and Skill Development:

    • Core team expertise building
    • General awareness training
    • Role-specific skills development
    • Certification and qualification
    • Knowledge sharing mechanisms

  3. Workflow and Process Design:

    • Clear responsibility assignment
    • Stage-gate process development
    • Quality control checkpoints
    • Progress tracking mechanisms
    • Continuous improvement feedback

Outsourcing Considerations

When to use external resources:

  1. When to Consider Outsourcing:

    • Large document volumes
    • Specialized expertise needs
    • Temporary capacity requirements
    • Tight deadlines
    • Complex remediation challenges

  2. Vendor Selection Criteria:

    • Accessibility expertise
    • Quality assurance processes
    • Capacity and scalability
    • Security and confidentiality
    • Cost and timeline considerations

  3. Managing Outsourced Remediation:

    • Clear requirements specification
    • Quality standards definition
    • Sample approval process
    • Progress monitoring
    • Knowledge transfer planning

Preventing Future Accessibility Debt

Building sustainable accessibility practices:

Creating Accessible Templates

Preventing issues at the source:

  1. Template Development:

    • Build accessibility into templates
    • Create accessible styles
    • Develop structure guidelines
    • Include accessibility features
    • Test templates thoroughly

  2. Implementation Strategy:

    • Replace inaccessible templates
    • Train users on accessible features
    • Provide usage guidelines
    • Monitor template effectiveness
    • Update based on feedback

  3. Template Management:

    • Centralized template repository
    • Version control and updates
    • Accessibility verification process
    • User support resources
    • Regular review and improvement

Training Content Creators

Building organizational capability:

  1. Training Program Components:

    • Accessibility awareness
    • Document creation best practices
    • Tool-specific techniques
    • Testing and verification skills
    • Remediation approaches

  2. Role-Specific Training:

    • Author/creator training
    • Designer training
    • Developer training
    • Quality assurance training
    • Management awareness

  3. Ongoing Education:

    • Refresher training
    • Updates on standards changes
    • Skill development opportunities
    • Knowledge sharing sessions
    • Resource availability

Implementing Accessibility Checkpoints

Building accessibility into workflows:

  1. Creation Process Integration:

    • Accessibility requirements definition
    • Early-stage accessibility reviews
    • Pre-publication verification
    • Approval checkpoints
    • Post-publication monitoring

  2. Tool Integration:

    • Authoring tool accessibility features
    • Automated checking integration
    • Workflow system connections
    • Reporting and tracking tools
    • Remediation tool availability

  3. Governance and Oversight:

    • Clear accountability
    • Regular compliance reporting
    • Performance metrics
    • Continuous improvement processes
    • Executive visibility

Conclusion

Retrofitting existing PDFs for accessibility is a significant undertaking, but one that yields important benefits in terms of legal compliance, audience reach, and organizational reputation. By implementing a strategic approach that includes assessment, prioritization, and efficient remediation techniques, organizations can successfully address their legacy document accessibility challenges.

The most effective retrofitting strategies combine appropriate tools like RevisePDF with well-designed processes, skilled personnel, and ongoing quality assurance. Remember that retrofitting is not just about fixing past issues—it's also an opportunity to implement better practices for the future, preventing the creation of new accessibility barriers.

While the task may seem daunting, especially for organizations with large document libraries, a phased approach focused on high-priority documents can make the process manageable. By combining retrofitting efforts with prevention strategies like accessible templates and creator training, organizations can gradually improve their overall document accessibility while efficiently addressing their most critical needs.

Need to make your existing PDF documents accessible to everyone? Visit RevisePDF.com for easy-to-use tools that help you assess, fix, and verify PDF accessibility without specialized software or technical expertise.

Top comments (0)