34 times in three weeks, I opened Obsidian to capture something and closed it without writing a single word. I logged every instance. The tool had become intimidating enough that my brain was quietly vetoing the capture before it started — not because I was lazy, but because the filing overhead had become its own cognitive tax.
The culprit was the decision stack. With PARA and 23 active plugins, every capture required a small negotiation: tag it, assign a project property, decide if "content pipeline" is a Project or a Resource this week. Tiago Forte's system is elegant in theory. At 20 context switches a day, it's just friction with good branding.
Switching to Tana cut that down in a measurable way. I ran both tools in parallel for six weeks — same projects, same capture habits — and timed the capture flow directly. Average time to log an action item in Obsidian: 47 seconds, including navigation to the right note. Average in Tana: 11 seconds. The difference is Tana's supertag system: you type the item, hit a shortcut for your Task type, assign a project field, and it's indexed automatically. No filing decision. No folder negotiation. The item surfaces in your project view without you choosing where it lives.
The tradeoff is real, though, and worth being honest about: Tana's export is not clean markdown. It's a structured JSON-ish format that took me two hours to make partial sense of. My Obsidian vault is a folder of plain text files I can open anywhere, forever. Tana's data lives in Tana. That's not a dealbreaker for me, but it's a genuine portability risk that the enthusiast community tends to wave away too quickly.
I also lost the backlink graph — which I'll admit I used for more than vanity. It occasionally surfaced real connections: two client projects sharing the same constraint, a theme threading through unrelated research. Tana has no equivalent. You only find what you know to search for.
I wrote up the full breakdown — including how I rebuilt my daily note template in Tana after four days of failed attempts, and what I'd tell someone still on the fence — over on dailyfocusmag.
Top comments (0)