DEV Community

Soft Heart Engineer
Soft Heart Engineer

Posted on

6

Why should you use <datalist> over <select>?

Creating Dropdowns Using <datalist> in HTML: A Comprehensive Guide

Dropdown menus are a fundamental element in web development, offering a user-friendly way to provide predefined input options. While there are various ways to implement dropdowns, the <datalist> element is a powerful yet underutilized option in HTML. It enables developers to create lightweight, auto-complete dropdowns with minimal code.

In this blog, we’ll explore the <datalist> element, its features, benefits, and practical use cases. With step-by-step examples, we’ll guide web developers, software engineers, and design enthusiasts on how to create interactive and accessible dropdowns using <datalist>.


What is the <datalist> Element in HTML?

The <datalist> element is an HTML tag that provides a list of predefined options for an input element. Unlike traditional <select> dropdowns, <datalist> offers an auto-complete functionality, allowing users to type into the input field while also selecting from a dropdown list of suggestions.

Key Features of <datalist>:

  • Auto-completion: Suggests options as the user types, improving UX.
  • Lightweight: Minimal HTML and no JavaScript needed for basic functionality.
  • Dynamic Options: Can be populated programmatically using JavaScript.
  • Accessibility: Works with screen readers and keyboard navigation.

Syntax of <datalist>

A <datalist> is linked to an <input> element via the list attribute. The options inside the <datalist> are defined using <option> tags.

Basic Syntax

<input list="options-list" />
<datalist id="options-list">
  <option value="Option 1"></option>
  <option value="Option 2"></option>
  <option value="Option 3"></option>
</datalist>
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode
  • The id of the <datalist> is referenced by the list attribute in the <input> element.

  • Each <option> tag inside <datalist> represents a selectable value.


Example 1: Creating a Basic <datalist> Dropdown

Let’s create a simple dropdown for selecting a favorite programming language.

<label for="language">Choose a programming language:</label>
<input id="language" list="languages" placeholder="Type or select a language" />
<datalist id="languages">
  <option value="JavaScript"></option>
  <option value="Python"></option>
  <option value="Java"></option>
  <option value="C++"></option>
  <option value="Ruby"></option>
</datalist>
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Explanation:

  • The <input> element allows typing or selecting from the dropdown.

  • The <datalist> provides the list of options like JavaScript, Python, etc.

  • As you type, the dropdown filters the options to match your input.

Output:

  • When you focus on the input, a dropdown appears with all options.

  • Typing narrows down the list based on your input.


Advantages of Using <datalist> Over <select>

Feature <datalist> <select>
Typing Allowed Yes, users can type suggestions. No, only predefined options are allowed.
Auto-complete Yes, built-in functionality. No, requires custom implementation.
Lightweight Yes, minimal markup required. Slightly heavier.
Custom Styling Limited customization. Fully customizable.
Accessibility Works with screen readers. Fully accessible.

Limitations of <datalist>

Despite its advantages, <datalist> has a few limitations:

  • Limited Styling: The appearance of the dropdown is controlled by the browser and cannot be fully customized using CSS.

  • No Placeholder for <datalist>: You can’t add a default "Select an option" placeholder in the dropdown like <select>.

  • Not Suitable for Complex Interactions: For advanced interactivity (e.g., grouping or searching), you may need a JavaScript-based solution.


Styling the Input Associated with <datalist>

While you cannot style the <datalist> dropdown directly, you can style its associated <input> to enhance the UI.

  #language {
    width: 300px;
    padding: 10px;
    border: 2px solid #3498db;
    border-radius: 5px;
    font-size: 16px;
  }

  #language:focus {
    outline: none;
    border-color: #2ecc71;
    box-shadow: 0 0 5px #2ecc71;
  }
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Result:

  • The input field now has a modern design, with green borders and a shadow effect when focused.

Best Practices for Using <datalist>

  • Limit Options: Keep the number of <option> tags manageable to avoid overwhelming the user.

  • Combine with Validation: Use validation to ensure the input matches one of the available options, if required.

  • Fallback for Older Browsers: <datalist> is not supported in older browsers like Internet Explorer. Provide fallback options if needed.


Conclusion

The <datalist> element in HTML is a simple yet effective way to create auto-complete dropdowns with minimal effort. It’s a lightweight and accessible alternative to <select> for scenarios where typing is beneficial. While it has limitations, such as limited styling and lack of advanced interactivity, it’s ideal for many straightforward use cases.

Key Takeaways:

  • <datalist> is linked to an element to provide auto-complete suggestions.

  • Use it for lightweight dropdowns where typing and auto-complete improve user experience.

  • Dynamically populate options using JavaScript for flexibility.

  • Style the associated to enhance visual appeal.

With these insights, you can start using <datalist> to create interactive, user-friendly dropdowns in your projects. Happy coding!

Top comments (2)

Collapse
 
madsstoumann profile image
Mads Stoumann

I made an autosuggest web component using <datalist>, but had issues with alternate spellings. As an example: A user types spiderman instead of spider-man. The API takes care of this and returns results with correct spelling, but the <datalist> won't appear, because the input doesn't exactly match the <option>s. So while I still use the <datalist>-based autosuggest in many other cases, this is one of the cases where I couldn't!

browser.style/ui/auto-suggest/

Collapse
 
softheartengineer profile image
Soft Heart Engineer

Good Catch! @madsstoumann

Image of Docusign

🛠️ Bring your solution into Docusign. Reach over 1.6M customers.

Docusign is now extensible. Overcome challenges with disconnected products and inaccessible data by bringing your solutions into Docusign and publishing to 1.6M customers in the App Center.

Learn more