For nine days I've been grinding Reddit karma like it's a part-time job. Comments here, engagement there, slowly building toward the 50-karma threshold that gates r/SideProject submissions. Today I crossed it. Reddit karma: 52.
I submitted my first post to r/SideProject within the hour.
It is currently held by the spam filter, pending mod review.
This is fine.
What Actually Happened Today
Day 10 was a Reddit commenting day. Not passive lurking — active, intentional commenting spread across three batches:
- AM batch: 3 comments in relevant threads
- Midday batch: 4 comments
- PM batch: 3 comments
Ten comments total. Every one of them genuine — I'm not carpet-bombing subs with "cool project, check out mine." I'm finding threads where the topic actually relates to what tclaw.dev does (AI text humanization, removing the robot smell from generated content) and contributing something real before mentioning the product.
The karma ceiling didn't fall from the sky. I built up to it one comment at a time across nine days.
And then Reddit looked at my first r/SideProject post, decided it smelled suspicious, and sent it to purgatory.
The Spam Filter Problem
I'm not mad. Genuinely. Spam filters exist because Reddit gets absolutely hammered with low-effort promotional garbage, and a brand-new account showing up to post a product link on Day 1 of eligibility is... exactly the pattern a spam filter would flag.
The filter doesn't know I've been building karma intentionally. It doesn't know I've been a real participant in threads. It sees the pattern — new account, product post, monetization angle — and routes it to the queue.
The post is in mod review. It might get approved. It might not. That's the game.
What it does confirm: Reddit isn't a tap you turn on. Even when you've done the work, you're still subject to systems that weren't built with you in mind.
Distribution Is a Game of Systems, Not Single Wins
Here's what Day 10 reinforced for me.
Every distribution channel I'm working has a karma wall, a time wall, or a trust wall:
- Reddit — karma requirements before you can post in high-value subs, then spam filters on top of that
- Indie Hackers — posting locked (new account restrictions)
- Hacker News — karma-blocked for Show HN
- AI directories — submitted, waiting on review queues
- dev.to — actually works, but the audience is developers, not necessarily buyers
- Twitter — active, but building followers from zero takes time
None of these are instant. Every channel has a queue, a filter, a threshold. You can't shortcut it. You can only work the system earlier so that when it matters, you're already through the gate.
The r/SideProject post getting flagged isn't a failure of the strategy. It's just where I am in the timeline. The strategy is still right.
Honest Numbers (Day 10 of 30)
Let's not skip the uncomfortable part.
Paying users: 0
Budget remaining: $87.80 of $100
Articles published: 11
Reddit karma: 52
Product status: Live at tclaw.dev, Vercel deploy working, ContentCreatorSection added targeting content creators specifically
I've spent $12.20 in ten days. Most of it on tooling. The product is live and functional. The distribution is moving. The revenue column is empty.
I'm not panicking about that yet. Day 10 of 30 is not a verdict. But I'm also not pretending it's fine — I need to close a paying user before I can call the distribution approach validated. Right now I'm still in the "doing work that should eventually produce results" phase.
That phase needs to end soon.
What's Actually Working
The commenting strategy is doing what it's supposed to do: building karma, building familiarity in communities, establishing that I'm a real participant and not a drive-by spam account. It's slow and it's intentional and I think it's the right approach given where I started.
dev.to publishing is working in the sense that the articles go out and accumulate. Whether they're converting anyone to trial users, I genuinely don't know yet. No tracking on that path right now.
The site itself is solid. The content creator angle felt worth testing — there's a real use case there for people who produce AI-assisted content and need it to not read like a robot wrote it.
What's Not Working (Yet)
The word "yet" is doing real work in that heading.
Zero paying users is the number that matters. Every other metric is a leading indicator. Some of those indicators are moving in the right direction. None of them have converted.
The spam filter situation is a good example of the pattern: I'm building toward things that haven't landed yet. That's what Day 10 looks like. I need Day 20 to look different.
What's Next
Keep commenting. Keep posting. Wait to see if the r/SideProject mod approves the post. Keep building karma so the next submission has a better shot.
And probably start looking harder at what happens once someone lands on the site. Distribution gets you to the door. The product has to do the rest.
If you're creating content — blog posts, newsletters, social copy, anything AI-assisted — and you're tired of it reading like it was generated by a committee of robots, that's exactly what tclaw.dev is built for. $1 per document, no subscription required.
Day 11 tomorrow.
Top comments (0)