Every week our team reads a lot of posts from people who run communities, sell courses or build an audience online. We build community and membership software for a living, so it's partly our job and partly our habit.
Again and again, one theme keeps turning up, from people who don't know each other and don't agree on much: "I don't actually own this."
We counted. More than 30 different people across the networks and communities we follow raised some version of it in a short space of time. None of this is a survey. It's a pattern we kept seeing, and below is our attempt to sum it up fairly, disagreements included.
The four ways people got the wake-up call
1. The account just disappeared.
This was the loudest group. A creator woke up to find YouTube had removed the channel, with very little explanation. Another person had a Discord account hacked and lost a server with more than ten thousand members. Someone else spent over a month waiting on Discord support after losing access to several community servers. A WhatsApp group with hundreds of leads was suspended right before a webinar. Elsewhere, a founder said their new communities were banned almost as soon as they started them.
What struck us was how calm the advice from other people in those threads was. Over and over it came down to one line: keep your content and your member list somewhere you control, so a ban is an inconvenience and not the end.
2. The money got held.
A smaller group, with sharper pain. Several sellers described a payments platform holding most of their revenue in reserve for months, with support that seemed to be automated. Other people asked the obvious follow-up, "so should I use Skool or Whop?", and replies split.
The honest correction, which a few people made too, is that running checkout on your own site doesn't make you immune. Card processors can still hold funds. What changes is that one layer between you and your money is gone, and you deal with the processor directly.
3. The fees started to add up.
Several people did the math out loud. One asked at what point handing a tenth of a big newsletter's revenue to the platform stops making sense. Another pointed out a growth fee that's turned on by default and takes a cut of every renewal. Others just called the fees ridiculous.
But here's the disagreement: plenty of replies argued the fee is the product. The platform handles payments, discovery and the network effect, and for a lot of people that's worth it.
4. The structure didn't fit.
This one's quieter but interesting. A coach said they'd been paying around $99 a month for a platform where they couldn't change how content was organised. A finance creator with a big following weighed Discord against Substack because they weren't ready to take on the problems that come with chat, like moderation and messages scrolling away. And a surprisingly nostalgic thread asked whether anyone else missed old-school forums. Lots of people did, and several replies pointed out that those communities haven't gone away. They've just moved into private servers that nobody can find.
Where the voices disagreed (and why that matters)
If this were only a "leave the platforms" story, it would be easy to write. It isn't.
- Convenience is real. One creator building on their own site worried that joining a platform like Patreon is simply easier for fans. They're not wrong. Every extra sign-up step costs you members.
- "Just vibe-code it" has a cost. One builder admitted they'd coded their own Skool clone to avoid the platform fee and found it slower than they needed it to be. Billing, failed renewals, moderation and spam are dull problems, and they're the problems that eat weekends.
- Self-hosted chat isn't a free win. One person moved a community to self-hosted chat because at least they owned it, then admitted it felt clunky.
- Spreading out can just mean more landlords. One creator put it as five platforms meaning five landlords, and then picked one hosted platform anyway, deciding that a single, deliberate dependency beats five accidental ones.
So the useful question isn't "platform or own site?" It's: which parts of your community can you not afford to lose?
A practical way to think about it
Here's the framework we'd suggest after reading all of this. It works whatever tools you use.
Things you should own no matter what:
- Your member list and their email addresses, exported regularly
- Your paid content (videos, lessons, files), backed up somewhere you control
- Your domain, so links survive a platform move
Things it's fine to rent:
- Discovery and reach (social feeds, YouTube, marketplaces)
- Real-time chat, if your members like it there
- Payments infrastructure, as long as you know the reserve and payout terms before you scale
Things worth deciding on purpose:
- Where the archive lives. Chat is great for "right now," but bad for "how did we fix this last March?" That's why several people who run help channels said they'd moved support to something searchable.
- Who you can reach if you get banned tomorrow. If the answer is "nobody," that's the gap to close first.
A lot of the calmest people in these threads had a simple setup: reach on the big platforms, a home on their own domain, and an email list that connects the two. It's not exciting. It works.
The bit we're still unsure about
We build tools for the "own your home" side of this, so we're biased. We'll say that plainly. We still don't think owning everything is right for everyone. A first-time creator with 50 members probably should use the easiest hosted option and focus on the people. The maths changes at some point: a certain revenue, a certain member count, or the first time an account gets flagged. We don't think anyone has a clean answer for where that point is.
That's why we'd rather ask than tell.
Your turn
- Have you ever lost access to a channel, server, group or payout? What did you wish you'd backed up beforehand?
- Where's your line? At what member count or revenue did a platform's fee or rules stop feeling worth it, or has it never happened?
- Chat vs forum vs feed: if you run a community, where does your archive live, and do your members actually search it?
- For those who moved off a platform: what was harder than you expected, and what turned out to be easier?
We read every comment, and we'd especially love to hear from people who tried owning it and went back to a hosted platform. That side of the story is under-told.
Top comments (0)