When it comes to project feasibility modeling, one of the trickiest parts is cashflow analysis.
Financial analysts love metrics like IRR, NPV, and Payback, but for developers, the real headache comes when cashflows are irregular — not evenly spaced monthly or yearly.
That’s where things get messy: Excel’s IRR assumes equal periods, while real-world projects don’t work that way.
The Developer Problem
Let’s take a simple case:
If you try to use standard IRR functions, you’ll quickly see the problem — they expect equal time gaps. The result can be totally misleading.
Why XIRR Matters?
The XIRR function (popular in Excel) solves this by using actual dates, not fixed periods.
But when implementing it in code, devs run into:
Convergence issues with Newton-Raphson iterations.
Multiple IRR roots when cashflows flip signs.
Performance slowdowns for large-scale simulations.
A Python Example
This works, but numpy.irr doesn’t support irregular dates out of the box.
To fix this, you need a root-finding algorithm (scipy.optimize.newton) on top of xnpv.
How We Approached It at Feasibility.Pro
When building Feasibility.Pro, our challenge was:
Handle any cashflow frequency (daily, quarterly, random).
Run sensitivity & scenario analysis on thousands of cases quickly.
Ensure numerical stability so results converge consistently.
We solved this by:
Using robust root-finding methods (Brent’s method > Newton’s in some cases).
Implementing vectorized operations to scale across large datasets.
Building fallback checks when multiple IRRs exist (e.g., picking the most relevant economic root).
Lessons for Developers
Don’t trust plain IRR unless cashflows are evenly spaced.
Use XIRR logic (date-based discounting) for realistic results.
Always stress-test with weird cashflow patterns (negative → positive → negative).
Performance tuning matters if you’re running simulations (think 10,000+ scenarios).
Discussion
Have you ever implemented IRR/XIRR outside Excel?
Which libraries or algorithms worked best for you?
Would you prefer a ready-to-use XIRR library for Python/JS, or roll your own?
At Feasibility.Pro, we’ve built these learnings into our platform — but I’d love to hear how other devs solve this problem in their own workflows.
Top comments (0)