When building a digital health solution, selecting the right backend is a foundational decision that impacts your development timeline, compliance burden, and long-term scalability. Two of the most powerful options are Medplum and Hapi FHIR, but they serve fundamentally different purposes. While both handle FHIR data expertly, one is a comprehensive, all-in-one platform, and the other is a robust library for building a custom FHIR layer.
Medplum: The Full-Stack Enterprise Platform
Think of Medplum as a headless EHR or a "Firebase for healthcare." It's a complete, enterprise-grade platform designed to be the single source of truth for your healthcare data. Medplum provides a FHIR-native API, user authentication, access control, and a full suite of tools right out of the box. Its primary value is in accelerating innovation by providing a scalable, compliant, and feature-rich foundation.
Key Advantages for Digital Health Solutions:
- Accelerated Development: Medplum allows your team to focus on building your application’s unique features rather than on backend infrastructure, compliance, or data management. This drastically reduces development time and speeds up your go-to-market.
- Built-in Compliance: For any organization, from a startup to a large enterprise, navigating regulations like HIPAA and SOC 2 is a significant challenge. Medplum is built with these compliance standards in mind, providing secure hosting, audit logging, and access controls that help you meet regulatory requirements from day one.
- Enterprise-Grade Scalability: Medplum is designed to scale effortlessly, supporting everything from a small pilot project to solutions serving tens of millions of patients on a single cluster. It offers a reliable, managed solution that grows with your organization.
HAPI FHIR: The Custom FHIR Facade Toolkit
The Hapi FHIR server is a robust and widely-used open-source Java library for building FHIR servers. It provides the essential functionality for storing, retrieving, and managing data in the FHIR standard. Unlike Medplum, Hapi FHIR is a toolkit, not a full platform. Its greatest strength lies in its ability to serve as a custom FHIR facade.
Key Advantages for Digital Health Solutions:
- Legacy System Integration: Hapi FHIR is an excellent choice for organizations that need to modernize an existing system. By building a custom FHIR facade with Hapi, you can expose a modern FHIR API that translates data from your legacy backend without a costly and risky full-scale migration.
- Ultimate Control: As a self-hosted, open-source library, Hapi FHIR gives your team complete control over your hosting environment, infrastructure, and every line of code. This is ideal for organizations with unique security, regulatory, or infrastructure requirements.
- Cost Flexibility: The library itself is free, which offers cost flexibility. However, it’s important to account for the total cost of ownership, including the significant investment in development time, server management, and ongoing compliance.
A Clearer Choice for Your Project
The decision between Medplum and Hapi FHIR is best framed not by the size of your organization, but by your project’s core objective.
| Feature | Medplum | Hapi FHIR |
|---|---|---|
| Best for... | Building new applications on a scalable, compliant, and managed platform. | Creating a custom FHIR API layer (facade) to wrap a legacy system. |
| Development Speed | Faster, with a comprehensive, ready-to-use platform. | Slower, as you must build and integrate the entire backend yourself. |
| Compliance | Built-in and managed, reducing your operational burden. | DIY, requiring internal resources to implement and maintain. |
| Control | High degree of customization through its API and SDKs. | Complete control over every aspect of the backend code and infrastructure. |
Choose Medplum if your goal is to build a new, innovative application and you want a scalable, compliant, and secure platform that allows you to move quickly. Medplum is the path of least resistance for both startups and large enterprises seeking to launch new products efficiently.
Choose Hapi FHIR if your primary objective is to modernize an existing legacy system by giving it a FHIR interface, and you have the technical expertise and resources to build and manage a custom backend solution from the ground up.
Top comments (0)