Practical Guidelines for Feature Selection

Building machine learning models isn’t just about choosing the right algorithm. The real power comes from feeding your model the right features — and removing the ones that add noise, redundancy, or unnecessary complexity.
This is where feature selection plays a central role.
Once you’ve collected and cleaned your dataset, you should never push all available features into a model and expect high accuracy. Real-world data is messy, biased, redundant, and often overloaded with irrelevant variables.

Preprocessing — especially feature transformation and feature selection — determines how well your model will perform.
In this updated guide, we’ll walk through foundational feature selection techniques using R, demonstrate practical code, and show how different models measure variable importance.

Table of Contents

Why Modeling Isn’t the Final Step
Understanding Correlation and Its Role in Feature Selection
Calculating Feature Importance with Regression
Using the caret Package for Feature Importance
Using Random Forest for Feature Importance
Practical Guidelines for Feature Selection
Complete R Code

1. Why Modeling Isn’t the Final Step
   Every analytics project has two sides:
   Business side — defining the problem, constraints, requirements
   Technical side — collecting data, cleaning, transforming, modeling
   The business side wraps around the technical process. A highly accurate model is not the end goal. Decision-makers want explainable insights they can trust and act on.
   A model that works but cannot be understood is a black box — and black boxes rarely make it into production.
   This is why variable importance matters:
   You see which features drive predictions
   You identify features with little or negative contribution
   You simplify models without losing performance
   You build trust with stakeholders
   You reduce compute cost and improve deployment speed
   This aligns with Occam’s Razor:
   The simplest model that works is usually the best.
   Feature selection helps you focus on the 20% of features that drive 80% of results.

2. The Role of Correlation
   Correlation is the simplest way to evaluate linear relationships between features and the target.
   Works well for regression
   Provides a quick, initial ranking
   Helps detect redundant or highly correlated features
   Example workflow:
   library(clusterGeneration)
   S = genPositiveDefMat("unifcorrmat", dim = 15)

library(mnormt)
n = 5000
X = rmnorm(n, varcov = S$Sigma)

Y = rbinom(n, size = 1, prob = 0.3)
data = data.frame(Y, X)

cor(data, data$Y)

In a synthetic dataset like this, correlations will be near zero.
But in real projects, variables with strong positive or negative correlations often become strong predictors.

1. Feature Importance Using Regression Regression models naturally quantify variable importance using: Coefficient magnitude p-values Significance levels Example (Logistic Regression): library(mlbench) data(PimaIndiansDiabetes) data_lm = as.data.frame(PimaIndiansDiabetes)

fit_glm = glm(diabetes ~ ., data_lm, family = "binomial")
summary(fit_glm)

You’ll see:
*** highly significant predictors
Positive or negative coefficient direction
Variables like glucose, mass, and pregnant often emerge as important
Regression-based importance works best for linear relationships and is intuitive for stakeholders.

1. Using caret::varImp() for a Unified Interface The caret package provides a consistent method to compute variable importance across many algorithms. library(caret) varImp(fit_glm)

This output aligns with model-based significance, ranking predictors based on their contribution.
Why it’s useful:
Works across dozens of models
Lets you compare importance consistently
Simplifies automation in pipelines

1. Random Forest for Feature Importance Random Forests are powerful because they: Handle nonlinearities Capture interactions Are robust to noise Provide strong importance metrics Fit a model: library(randomForest) fit_rf = randomForest(diabetes ~ ., data = data_lm) importance(fit_rf) varImp(fit_rf) varImpPlot(fit_rf)

Random Forest evaluates feature importance using Mean Decrease Gini:
Higher values = bigger contribution to purity
Used heavily in high-dimensional data
Great for feature ranking prior to modeling
This method is useful when:
Data is nonlinear
Many features interdepend
You want model-agnostic selection

1. Practical Guidelines for Feature Selection Now that you’ve explored multiple methods, here’s how to decide what to keep:
2. Use correlation as an early filter Remove features with correlations near zero Drop features with extreme multicollinearity (>0.9)
3. Use model-based methods for depth Regression for linear problems Random Forest for nonlinear structure varImp() for consistency
4. Look for sharp declines in importance Plot importance scores. Select features until you see a "knee" in the curve — where additional features contribute very little.
5. Use domain knowledge Ask: Is this feature meaningful in the real world? Is it derived from leaked future information? Should it logically matter for the target?
6. Keep a balanced number of features Avoid too few or too many. Rules of thumb: Keep variables covering 80–90% total importance Or keep top 20–30 variables in high-dimensional datasets Or use predictive error (RMSE/AUC) as a guide when testing subsets

Conclusion
Feature selection is not just a step in modeling — it’s a strategy to improve accuracy, speed, interpretability, and trust.
Whether you use:
Correlation
Regression significance
caret variable importance
Random Forest Gini importance
…your goal is the same: build a simpler, more powerful model that solves a real business challenge.
Removing noisy predictors improves:
Model performance
Training time
Deployment speed
Interpretability
Feature selection ensures that your model focuses on what matters most.

Complete R Code (Revised and Cleaned)
library(clusterGeneration)
S = genPositiveDefMat("unifcorrmat", dim = 15)

library(mnormt)
n = 5000
X = rmnorm(n, varcov = S$Sigma)

Y = rbinom(n, size = 1, prob = 0.3)
data = data.frame(Y, X)

cor(data, data$Y)

library(mlbench)
data(PimaIndiansDiabetes)
data_lm = as.data.frame(PimaIndiansDiabetes)

fit_glm = glm(diabetes ~ ., data_lm, family = "binomial")
summary(fit_glm)

library(caret)
varImp(fit_glm)

library(randomForest)
fit_rf = randomForest(diabetes ~ ., data = data_lm)
importance(fit_rf)
varImp(fit_rf)
varImpPlot(fit_rf)

At Perceptive Analytics, we help organizations transform data into a strategic advantage. Our comprehensive data analytics services enable businesses to uncover insights, optimize operations, and drive measurable performance improvements. Complementing this capability, our experienced Power BI Consultants design scalable dashboards, automate reporting, and deliver real-time visibility that empowers leaders to make informed decisions with confidence.