Single page apps are pretty cool. I like them a lot and they are fun to create.
However, they can get quite heavy in terms of code size, and loading time. You also have to jump through many hoops to get server side rendering. These things can be worth the time an effort, but not always.
I think there is a case to be made for a many tool solution.
Here's what are transitioning to at DropConfig.
We have a lot of pages that just list things. List your organizations, list your repos, list your configs. Why are we bringing the big guns to bear on this? Why bloat a simple listing page with as much react as possible? Previously I'd have to drag in React, and Redux as well as Material-UI. It's a lot of things for a simple listing page.
This is where Stimulus and Turbolinks come in handy.
On our backend, in node, we use ejs to render listing pages.
The server just returns plain HTML. We then rely on Turbolinks to make the page loads feel more like an SPA. But we never send anything from our Server but plain HTML. This keeps our pages really light and they render fast!
There's a few big wins, in my opinion, in writing plain HTML templates
- Making a simple HTML template on your server where the data already lives is far easier than doing it in React.
- No calls to fetch JSON and loading states.
- No Redux for state management etc.
- The same JSON REST APIs we make can we used to render the templates server side.
Stimulus is used for mundane operations on the DOM. Things like menu toggles, modals, etc. It's a really nice and simple too for such things. It's worth a look at least. Basecamp uses it. (And Turbolinks)
So where does React come in? Well we have a configuration editor. It has a lot of data and a lot of moving parts. That would be tough to do with Stimulus and Turbolinks so we rely on React to handle it for us. With the ease of code splitting in modern tools like webpack, the user doesnt have to download all that extra bulk until they want to edit a configuration.
In case you don't think there is any precedent for this, consider GitHub. This is more or less how their entire frontend functions. While I don't think they use stimulus and I know they use pjax instead of Turbolinks, it is the same sort of concepts.
Side note: Check out Tailwind CSS it fucking rocks. Maybe I'll write about it someday.
Thanks for listening to me ramble.
Feel free to ask me any questions. I know some things about some other things.
Check out DropConfig you might like it.