What started as an effort to protect children online is now reshaping the internet itself. Policies requiring ID checks, facial scans, and AI-powered age predictions are becoming the norm, and YouTube is the latest major platform to follow that path. But safety at this scale might come at a cost: anonymity, autonomy, and access.
UK: The Online Safety Act Takes Effect
As of July 25, 2025, the UK’s Online Safety Act 2023 mandates robust age verification for platforms hosting adult or potentially harmful content. This includes social media, forums, dating apps, and even gaming content. Methods permitted include facial age estimation, government ID verification, or credit card checks. Platforms like Reddit, X, Discord, and Spotify have already deployed such systems.
While these regulations aim to safeguard minors, they have faced criticism for undermining user privacy and increasing the risk of data breaches and surveillance. As a result, public concern has driven a sharp rise in VPN usage since the Act was implemented.
Australia: Age Checks Are Coming to Search Engines
Australia is moving forward with one of the most ambitious online safety measures to date. Starting December 27, 2025, search engines like Google will be required to implement age verification systems for logged-in users, based on new codes set by the eSafety Commissioner. The goal is to restrict access to harmful or inappropriate content and to enforce SafeSearch by default for minors. Methods could include facial age estimation, ID verification, or analysis of account data. Companies that fail to comply could face penalties of up to AUD 50 million, making it one of the strictest enforcement regimes in the world.
YouTube’s New AI‑Powered Age System
Beginning August 13, 2025, YouTube will launch an AI-driven system to estimate users’ ages based on factors like search behavior, watch history, and account maturity. If the AI flags a user as a teenager, YouTube will enforce teen-specific viewing protections: personalized ads disabled, digital well-being tools activated, and stricter content recommendations. Users can appeal by submitting a government ID or credit card to prove they are over 18.
While new age-verification systems are framed as protective measures, they raise difficult questions about security, anonymity, and individual freedom. Requiring facial scans, ID uploads, or behavioral profiling to access everyday content introduces serious risks, not only from potential data breaches, but from how this information could be used.
Governments may claim these systems are for safety, but centralized age data could easily become a tool for surveillance, content control, or political targeting. And with enforcement often outsourced to private companies, the line between regulation and corporate overreach becomes dangerously blurred.
It’s important to recognize that tools like parental controls, such as YouTube Kids or content filters on streaming services, already provide tailored ways for families to manage what children watch. These solutions offer more flexibility and respect for privacy than broad government mandates. While lawmakers have a role in setting safe standards, much of the responsibility lies with parents to actively guide their children’s online experiences.
Relying too heavily on legislation can result in excessive surveillance and large-scale data collection, posing risks not only from governments but also from third parties who may gain access to this sensitive information. A balanced approach, combining effective parental controls with thoughtful regulation, seems more promising than sweeping laws that may undermine both security and freedom.
References
Beser, J. (2025, 31 July). Extending our built-in protections to more teens on YouTube. blog.youtube. https://blog.youtube/news-and-events/extending-our-built-in-protections-to-more-teens-on-youtube/
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology. (2025, 23 July). Online Safety Act. GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/online-safety-act#:~:text=to%20monitor%20compliance.-,Child%20Safety,suicide%20or%20eating%20disorder%20content.
Taylor, J. (2025, 20 July). Face age and ID checks? Using the internet in Australia is about to fundamentally change. The Guardian. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/jul/20/face-age-and-id-checks-using-the-internet-in-australia-is-about-to-fundamentally-change
Top comments (0)