DEV Community

Cover image for LLM Evals - The Trap No Oneโ€™s Telling You ๐Ÿ”
Louis Dupont
Louis Dupont

Posted on • Edited on

LLM Evals - The Trap No Oneโ€™s Telling You ๐Ÿ”

We hear it more and more: โ€˜Use LLM Evaluations to guide your AI project.โ€™ And for a good reasonโ€”metrics are essential.

Yet, thereโ€™s a trap nobody talks about...

Letโ€™s say you have a chatbot and want to introduce metrics. You find tools that compute metrics like 'Helpfulness', 'Conciseness', and 'Completeness'.
Sounds greatโ€”they promise to optimise your userโ€™s experience. Right?

Truth is, their correlation to real business value is often unclear. Is this really what your user cares about ? Will this increase adoption ?

Many teams end up measuring the wrong thing, thinking theyโ€™re being data-driven, while forgetting about what really matters.

Metrics arenโ€™t inherently good. Theyโ€™re only as useful as the questions they help you answer.

If you donโ€™t ask โ€˜What does success look like?โ€™ or โ€˜What is the goal I want to measure?โ€™ your metrics arenโ€™t leading youโ€”theyโ€™re misleading you.

So, the next time you set metrics, ask yourself: Are you measuring what impacts your business goalsโ€”or just whatโ€™s easy to quantify?

The difference might explain why your AI project feels stuck.

Because chasing the wrong metrics isnโ€™t progress. Itโ€™s running in circlesโ€”like a headless chicken.

Evaluation Trap

Top comments (4)

Collapse
 
ai_joddd profile image
Vinayak Mishra

I agree Louis there is a lot of fake hype created in the market around LLM evals, but parallely there are tools that are doing really good. For example, I learned about this tool called Maxim AI through this blog on LLM hallucination detection. This blog led me exploring their tool, and my agentic workflows have become so streamlined that while working, I can really 'enjoy' my coffee now instead of drinking it just as a stress-buster lol ;)

Collapse
 
louis-dupont profile image
Louis Dupont

Interesting! On my side I use Braintrust.dev and Langfuse for monitoring/eval, it looks like Maxim AI covers more or less the same space, I'll check it out to see exactly what they offer.

You said you are building agentic workflows, may I ask the scope of the project and if you are facing some limitations/blocking issues ?
I'm not specialised on agentic solutions, and I see many struggling to deliver value so I'm always curious to learn a little more about how people approach it :)

Collapse
 
ai_joddd profile image
Vinayak Mishra

Oh, nice to know you're using Brainstrust. So actually I was building a movie booking agent and faced the issue of simulating multi-turn conversations, but on Maxim I was able to access their agentic simulation feature and it's wonderful. I'd recommend you to give a shot to Maxim AI!

Collapse
 
matsumoto_osaka profile image
Matsumoto

Love it!