Gumroad vs Etsy for Digital Products: Which Made Me More Money?

I'll never forget the day I decided to take my digital products online. I had spent months creating a printable art bundle, and I was eager to share it with the world. I researched the best platforms to sell digital products and narrowed it down to two popular options: Gumroad and Etsy. I set up shops on both platforms and waited for the sales to roll in. But, I soon realized that one platform was outperforming the other in a big way.

As it turned out, my experience was not an isolated incident. A surprising statistic from Gumroad's own blog reveals that creators using Gumroad's "Pay what you want" feature reported an average increase of 23% in sales. Meanwhile, Etsy's own annual report shows that while the platform has over 30 million active buyers, the average seller earns only $430 per year.

In this article, I'll dive into my experience selling digital products on both Gumroad and Etsy, and provide actionable tips on how you can maximize your earnings on each platform.

Setting Up Shop

Before I dive into the results, let's take a look at how I set up my shops on both platforms.

• Gumroad: I created a simple product page for my printable art bundle, including a description, images, and a price point of $10. I also set up a custom domain and enabled Gumroad's sales tax automation feature to ensure I was compliant with tax laws.
• Etsy: I created a shop for my digital products, including a profile, profile picture, and cover photo. I listed my printable art bundle as a digital download, with a price point of $10. I also made sure to optimize my listing for Etsy's search algorithm by including relevant keywords.

The Results

After three months, here are the results:

• Gumroad: I sold 120 copies of my printable art bundle, earning a total of $1,200. My average sale price was $10, with a conversion rate of 2.5% (meaning 2.5% of visitors to my page made a purchase).
• Etsy: I sold 50 copies of my printable art bundle, earning a total of $500. My average sale price was $10, with a conversion rate of 1.2% (meaning 1.2% of visitors to my shop made a purchase).

The clear winner was Gumroad, with more than double the sales and a higher conversion rate.

Why Gumroad Won

So, what did I do differently on Gumroad that led to more sales? Here are a few key takeaways:

• Easy checkout process: Gumroad's checkout process is seamless and easy to use, with a minimal number of fields to fill out. This likely contributed to my higher conversion rate.
• Customizable product pages: Gumroad allows you to customize your product pages with images, videos, and descriptions. I made sure to include high-quality images and a detailed description of my printable art bundle.
• Built-in marketing tools: Gumroad offers built-in marketing tools, such as discount codes and affiliate programs, which I used to promote my product.

Why Etsy Fell Short

While Etsy is a popular platform for physical products, it may not be the best choice for digital products. Here are a few reasons why:

• Competition from physical products: Etsy's search results are dominated by physical products, making it harder for digital products to get noticed.
• Limited digital product features: Etsy's digital product features are limited, with no built-in support for variable pricing or subscription-based models.

Actionable Tips

If you're considering selling digital products on Gumroad or Etsy, here are three actionable tips to keep in mind:

• Optimize your product pages: Make sure your product pages are complete, including high-quality images and detailed descriptions.
• Use marketing tools: Take advantage of built-in marketing tools, such as discount codes and affiliate programs, to promote your products.
• Choose the right platform: Consider the strengths and weaknesses of each platform before choosing where to sell your digital products.

Next Steps

If you're ready to start selling digital products, here's what to do next:

• Sign up for Gumroad or Etsy and set up your shop.
• Create a digital product, such as a printable art bundle or an ebook.
• Follow the tips outlined above to maximize your earnings.

Don't wait – start selling your digital products today!

---

Ready to go deeper? Check out our guides at Upshift Team — use code UPSHIFT20 for 20% off.

---

More from Upshift Team: lufrax.gumroad.com | Code UPSHIFT20 for 20% off