"Think outside the box!"
Great advice. Incredibly helpful. One small problem: nobody knows where the box is.
What even is creativity, anyway?
Before we get to boxes and closed worlds and all that fun stuff, let's settle on what creativity actually means, because "be creative" is about as actionable as "be taller."
Creativity is when two things are both high at the same time: originality and usefulness. That's it. Something no one's ever seen before and something that actually works. Just weird? Not creative. Just useful? Also, not creative, that's just engineering. Both? That's the good stuff.
There's also simplicity in the mix, but let's not get greedy.
Why "think outside the box" is terrible advice
Here's what actually happens when you tell someone to think outside the box.
They imagine a box. Then they try to think around it. And because the box they imagined is shaped by the exact same problem they're trying to solve, they end up either with solutions so bizarre they'd never survive contact with reality, or they circle all the way back to the traditional solution they started with.
You've just run a very tiring mental exercise to arrive at the answer you already had. Congratulations.
The phrase also has another problem: in the real world, there are no boxes. No one drew a boundary around your problem and labeled it "the box." The "box" is just a metaphor that your brain takes too literally and then gets confused by.
The correct term, the one that actually helps, is the Closed World.
So what's the Closed World?
The Closed World was discovered by a researcher named Roni Horowitz, and the idea is almost annoyingly counterintuitive:
Ideas are more creative when they are confined to what's already around you.
Not outside. Not somewhere exotic. Right there. The resources, people, components, and constraints you already have are your closed world. And here's the punchline: constraints don't kill creativity. They enhance it.
Think about soldiers frying eggs on a shovel over a campfire because there's no pan. Or a forklift being used as an improvised cherry picker because there's no ladder tall enough. Nobody went outside their world to solve those problems. They looked at what they already had and asked: what else can this do?
That's the closed world doing its thing.
Why constraints are actually your friends
You'd think unlimited freedom would produce unlimited creativity. That sounds logical. It is also completely wrong.
When you have too many options, your brain does the creative equivalent of standing in front of a massive restaurant menu for twenty minutes and ordering a burger. You default to the familiar because the familiar is safe, and you're overwhelmed.
Constraints force your brain to actually work. When you can't reach outside the problem, you start looking at the problem differently. You start noticing things about what you have that you'd ignored before. Sometimes the solution was sitting right there the whole time, like the answer to a riddle you'd been overthinking.
The thing traditional thinking gets wrong about problems
Traditional thinking says: problems are bad, solutions are good. Get rid of the problem as fast as possible and replace it with a solution.
This sounds sensible. It is also why so many solutions are completely forgettable.
If you sprint away from a problem, you never actually understand it. And if you don't understand it, you can't use it. Because here's the thing: in many cases, the problem itself is part of the creative solution.
The problem contains information. It contains context. It contains constraints. And those constraints, if you work within them instead of around them, are exactly what will lead you to something original and useful, you know, the two things that make something creative.
Apollo 13, the ultimate closed world story
If you want to see closed world thinking in action at its most dramatic, look up the Apollo 13 CO2 filter problem. The astronauts had square filter cartridges. The ship needed round ones. People were going to die.
The engineers at NASA didn't order new parts. They couldn't. They couldn't go outside the closed world; they were literally 200,000 miles from the nearest hardware store.
So they sat down with exactly what was on that spacecraft and figured out how to fit a square peg in a round hole. And they did.
That's not thinking outside the box. That's thinking inside the only world available, and doing it brilliantly.
So what do you actually do with this?
Next time you're stuck on a problem, instead of trying to escape it, do this:
Draw your closed world. What people, tools, components, and resources are already part of this situation? What's right in front of you that you haven't thought to repurpose? What does the problem itself tell you about the solution?
Then stay there. Don't go looking for something exotic. The opportunity is usually right under your nose; you've just been too busy looking for a box to climb out of.
Stop thinking outside the box. Start thinking inside the closed world. The answers you need are probably already in the room.
Top comments (0)