I ran 50 cold emails through our AI roaster. The same mistakes came up over and over. Here they are with the fixes.
Reason 1: The subject line is about you
❌ Gets deleted: "Partnership opportunity from [Your Company]"
✅ Gets opened: "Your checkout — quick thought" or "Question about [specific thing they posted]"
Reason 2: The first line starts with "I"
❌ Deleted: "I am a freelance developer with 8 years of experience..."
✅ Read: "Your pricing page has 4 steps where your competitors average 2. I've fixed this for similar SaaS companies and cut abandonment by 30%."
Start with them. Your credentials can come in sentence 2 or 3.
Reason 3: It's too long
The optimal cold email length is 50-125 words. Every word you write after 100 is a word they're less likely to read.
The rule: if you can't say it in 3 sentences, you don't understand your own value prop yet.
Reason 4: The ask is too big
❌ Deleted: "Would you be open to scheduling a 45-minute discovery call to discuss how we might be able to work together?"
✅ Gets replies: "Worth a 10-minute call? I can show you exactly what I changed for a similar company."
Reason 5: It sounds like a template
The dead giveaway: "I've been following your company's innovative work." "I think there's a real opportunity for synergy."
The fix: say one specific thing that proves you looked at them.
The AI roast of a typical cold email
🔥 "This email opens with 'I hope this finds you well' — the email equivalent of starting a speech with 'Webster's dictionary defines...' It then spends two sentences describing the sender before mentioning the recipient. The CTA asks for a 30-minute call from someone who has given you zero reason to trust them with 5 minutes. Delete."
📧 Roast My Cold Email — Paste yours. Get specific feedback on exactly what's getting it deleted — free preview, $2 full report.
Originally published at conker.tools/blog/why-your-cold-email-gets-deleted
Top comments (0)