Google Duplex: Has AI Gone Too Far?

Did you find this post useful? Show some love!

I believe that AI voice is pre recorded/ or samples of pre recorded words/sentenses. I dont believe its true AI voice there, sorry I don't buy it...
Otherwise why not having those voices already available on our google assistants?

On the other hand, there is no need to be afraid of fake booking because the person booking will have to pre pay the appointment eventually... So.. for the salon it does not matter if its fake or not if it received the money anyway...

The article clearly says that the AI is trained just for a very small set of scenarios:

One of the key research insights was to constrain Duplex to closed domains, which are narrow enough to explore extensively. Duplex can only carry out natural conversations after being deeply trained in such domains. It cannot carry out general conversations.

I don't think they are lying, it would be a very bad business move ;-)

It will take a long time before we'll have it on our phones, there are too many nuances. Booking a meal is not the same as booking a doctor's appointment for example. And they also have to deal with all the languages we speak.

No, @miguelqueiroz is right. These are not (entirely) synthesized voices. I don't buy it either. +1 for noticing that, Miguel. :)

I'm not sure I get your point.

Either Google is lying on the world stage which though not impossible is highly unlikely or I'm not sure what you're trying to say

Either way we can't prove at which stage of development the technology is, in the meantime we're going to get John Legend's voice in the assistant

They don't say in the talk that the voice you hear is AI, they just shown what they wanted it to look like, or what they vision to do. I guess..

Ok so you think they just showed us the end goal instead of what the actual technology can do right now? Well, I think we'll never know then :-)

I don't think the demo was scripted. It was true, because CEO said it couple of times that they have several recordings like these that they would like to show.

Google Duplex is in advanced stages of development and we might be able to experience it in 2-3 years.

The demo was amazing. My first response was concern as I just kept thinking of ways this technology could be abused.
While this is an amazing feat by google, I gotta ask is it really necessary? Maybe this is a cultural difference between the USA and Europe/Croatia but it seems to me it shouldn't be that hard to book an appointment for oneself.
A friend weighed in with another idea. Maybe an AI could also take care of the receiving end of the conversation. So the hair saloon in this story would have an AI answer the phone as well and check for free time slots. I think this would step around the ethics problem that arrises when communicating with humans though it does seem to open up the possibility of causing damage to a business with fake bookings.

Another post on the subject:

With a few comments relevant here

I would say yes. Having a quick discussion with my brother about it I came up with the scenario of the Google AI being used to call businesses constantly to set up fake appointments.

A simple solution to this is to make the AI start the conversation like "Hi, this is Google Assistant calling on behalf of Joe Smith, I would like to make an appointment for him please".

Human on the other side knows it's an AI and can answer accordingly. Doesn't need to pretend to do formalities, can simply state fact. Both efficient and fair to the person on the otherside.

I also would say it is important for AI to be as humanised as possible, as we can all agree standard computer voices are annoying and most people would just hangup.

An AI / Assistant accepting voice as an input seems quite acceptable. It should have a "trigger word" (IE, "Alexa," or "Hey Google"), and otherwise clear it's memory of the sounds around it. We've gotten pretty

Voice as an output is way more ethically grey in my mind. I would agree with @scottishross that a disclaimer would be appropriate in these situations.

What happens when the AI gets confused and the conversation leaves it's pre-determined bounds? Without a disclaimer, things could get very crazy.


Hey there, we see you aren't signed in. (Yes you, the reader. This is a fake comment.)

Please consider creating an account on It literally takes a few seconds and we'd appreciate the support so much. ❀️

Plus, no fake comments when you're signed in. πŸ™ƒ

At the end of the video he asks "how far are we willing to go with these robot assistants?". We all know the answer to that question :-D

They make incredibly real looking ones in Japan and South Korea.

Classic DEV Post from Jan 12

What was the worst bug you've ever written?

So I just wrote my worst bug ever. The Practical Dev @thepracticalde...

Follow @ben to see more of their posts in your feed.
Meghan 🌺
21. Student. Dreamer. Doer. On a mission to change the world with code. she/her
Trending on
Why avoid Ruby's for .. in?
#healthydebate #discuss #ruby
How to Improve Your Development Experience
#beginners #career #development #productivity
Explain JavaScript Promises like I am five.
#discuss #explainlikeimfive #javascript
How do you manage projects?
#projectmanagement #freelance #developer #discuss
What is difference among enterprise architect, solution architect, software architect, system architect and cloud architect?
Thoughts on Dashboard Design
#data #dashboard #dataanalysis #productivity
What is top 5 most valuable courses in a CS Degree?
#discuss #help #beginners #devconfession
Juggling Multiple Languages Simultaneously