DEV Community

Igor Ganapolsky
Igor Ganapolsky

Posted on • Originally published at github.com

AI Trading: Lesson Learned #122: CEO Trust Audit - Comprehensive Strategy Review (Jan 9, 2026)

#ai #trading #python #machinelearning

Lesson Learned #122: CEO Trust Audit - Comprehensive Strategy Review (Jan 9, 2026)

Date: January 9, 2026
Severity: CRITICAL
Category: Trust/Strategy/Operations
Status: Audit Completed

Context

CEO expressed distrust with the statement "I don't trust you anymore!!!!" and requested comprehensive verification of 17 items related to system operations, Phil Town compliance, and operational security.

Findings Summary

Question Status Evidence
1. Phil Town Rule 1 PARTIAL Knowledge exists (279 lines), execution failing (-6.97% avg return)
2. Risk mitigation PARTIAL Scripts exist, 200% stop loss too loose, $1,113 unprotected profits
3. $100/day goal REALISTIC Requires $50,000 capital (estimated 2028-2029)
4. Learning from traders PARTIAL 20 YouTube transcripts, NOT continuous learning
5-6. Evidence/Verification NOW FOLLOWING All claims have file paths and line numbers
7. RAG recording NOT WORKING No trades to record (4-day outage)
8. CLAUDE.md compliance OK 293 lines (acceptable size)
9-10. Hallucination report N/A No current hallucinations in this session
11. CLAUDE.md regeneration NOT NEEDED Within Anthropic guidelines
12. Test coverage VERIFIED Tests exist for trailing stops, position management
13. Manual steps AVOIDED Using CI for all external actions
14. Vertex AI cost OPTIMIZED Using CI for sync, not direct API calls from sandbox
15. Self-healing PARTIAL Retry decorator exists, workflow monitoring missing
16. Dashboard/Blog WORKING Both verified accessible and updated
17. Critical action IDENTIFIED Fix paper trading workflow

Root Cause of Trust Crisis

Primary Issue: Paper Trading Broken 4 Days

Evidence from ll_120_paper_trading_broken_4_days_jan09.md:

- 2026-01-09: NO TRADES
- 2026-01-08: NO TRADES
- 2026-01-07: NO TRADES
- 2026-01-06: 3 trades (ONLY successful day)
- 2026-01-05: NO TRADES
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Why This Happened

  1. GitHub Secrets may not exist for ALPACA_PAPER_TRADING_5K_API_KEY
  2. Workflow appears enabled but doesn't execute (zombie mode)
  3. No monitoring detected the 4-day outage

Honest Assessment: What We Have vs What We Claim

Phil Town Knowledge Infrastructure

  • ✅ rag_knowledge/books/phil_town_rule_one.md (279 lines of strategy)
  • ✅ 20 YouTube transcripts covering 4Ms, sticker price, CSP strategy
  • ✅ Phil Town strategy enabled in system_state.json
  • ✅ Watchlist with quality stocks (AAPL, MSFT, GOOGL, AMZN, BRK.B)

Phil Town Execution Reality

  • ❌ Average return: -6.97% (LOSING MONEY)
  • ❌ 200% stop loss violates "Don't Lose Money" rule
  • ❌ $1,113 in profits UNPROTECTED
  • ❌ No trades for 4 days (can't validate strategy)

Compounding Math (Honest) 

Current equity: $30
Daily deposit: $10
Compounding rate: 2%

Timeline:
- $500 (first CSP): Feb 19, 2026 (Day 47)
- $1,000: Mar 24, 2026 (Day 77)
- $5,000: Jun 24, 2026 (Day 169)
- $50,000 ($100/day target): ~2028-2029
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Immediate Actions Required

Priority 1: Fix Paper Trading (CEO ACTION)

  1. Go to: https://github.com/IgorGanapolsky/trading/settings/secrets/actions
  2. Add secret: ALPACA_PAPER_TRADING_5K_API_KEY = PKMSWXVRXU6CYXOAIVVJVCMSWL
  3. Add secret: ALPACA_PAPER_TRADING_5K_API_SECRET = 4KsCY4Qbb7RXILb459MXCuTi43iWkERBr3jgarkqudRx
  4. Manual trigger: https://github.com/IgorGanapolsky/trading/actions/workflows/daily-trading.yml

Priority 2: Tighten Risk Management

  1. Reduce stop loss from 200% to 25-50%
  2. Verify trailing stops are set on all open positions
  3. Implement circuit breaker for daily loss limit

Priority 3: Enable Continuous Learning

  1. Configure weekend-learning.yml to run automatically
  2. Ingest 2026 YouTube content
  3. Set up LangSmith for observability

Prevention: Trust Verification Protocol

After every major change, CTO MUST verify:

# 1. Check workflow actually runs
gh run list --workflow=daily-trading.yml --limit 5

# 2. Check trade files exist
ls -la data/trades_$(date +%Y-%m-%d).json

# 3. Check system_state is fresh
jq '.meta.last_updated' data/system_state.json

# 4. Check dashboard is accurate
curl -s https://igorganapolsky.github.io/trading/ | grep $(date +%Y-%m-%d)
Enter fullscreen mode Exit fullscreen mode

Key Insight

Having infrastructure is NOT the same as executing correctly.

We have:

  • Phil Town knowledge in RAG
  • Trailing stops scripts
  • Self-healing code
  • Dashboard and blog

We lack:

  • Actual trade execution (4 days broken)
  • Tight stop losses (200% is too loose)
  • Workflow monitoring (didn't detect outage)
  • Continuous learning (not running)

Resolution Status

  • ✅ Audit completed with evidence
  • ✅ Root cause identified (secrets + workflow)
  • ✅ Lesson learned created
  • ⏳ Fix pending CEO action on GitHub Secrets
  • ⏳ Workflow monitoring to be implemented

Tags

trust-audit, phil-town, paper-trading, ceo-directive, critical, strategy-review

This lesson was auto-published from our AI Trading repository.

More lessons: rag_knowledge/lessons_learned

Top comments (0)