Mediation Resolves 70-80% of Cases. Courts Resolve the Rest.
Mediation is the most underused dispute resolution tool available. It's faster, cheaper, and less adversarial than court. Both parties have a say in the outcome rather than having a judge impose one.
The catch: mediation only works if both parties participate in good faith. And good faith starts with clear communication — proposing mediation professionally, preparing your position thoroughly, and engaging constructively during sessions.
These templates cover every stage of the mediation process, from initial proposal to final agreement.
Proposing Mediation
'Dear [Other Party], I'm writing to propose that we resolve our dispute regarding [brief description] through mediation rather than litigation. Why mediation: it's faster (weeks, not months or years), significantly cheaper (shared mediator fee vs. attorney fees), confidential (unlike public court records), and gives us both control over the outcome. I'm proposing: a professional mediator from [local mediation service/bar association], [half-day or full-day] session, with costs split equally. This proposal is made in good faith, without prejudice to my legal rights. If mediation doesn't resolve the matter, both of us retain the right to pursue other remedies. Would you be willing to try mediation before we escalate further?'
Proposing mediation signals strength, not weakness. Courts increasingly expect parties to attempt mediation before trial, and judges look favorably on the party who made the effort.
Mediation Position Statement
Sent to the mediator before the session:
'Dear [Mediator], here is my position statement for the mediation scheduled on [date]. Background: [factual summary of the dispute — chronological, specific, evidence-based]. My position: [what I believe happened and why the other party is responsible]. What I want: [specific desired outcome — dollar amount, action, agreement]. What I'm willing to consider: [areas of flexibility — you don't need to reveal your full flexibility, but showing willingness to negotiate demonstrates good faith]. Key documents: [list of exhibits I'll bring]. Concerns about the other party's likely position: [what you expect them to argue and your response]. I'm entering this mediation in good faith with a genuine desire to reach a fair resolution.'
The position statement is your first impression with the mediator. Be factual, organized, and honest about both your strengths and the areas where your case has weaknesses. Mediators are more effective when they understand the full picture.
During Mediation: Written Proposals
During joint or shuttle mediation, you may need to submit written settlement proposals:
'Settlement proposal: [Party A] will [specific terms — payment, action, timeline]. [Party B] will [specific terms]. Both parties agree to [mutual terms — confidentiality, non-disparagement, release of claims]. Payment schedule: [if applicable — amounts and dates]. Contingencies: [conditions that must be met]. This proposal expires at [time/date]. If accepted, this will serve as the basis for a formal settlement agreement to be signed by both parties today.'
Written proposals during mediation prevent misunderstandings. When emotions are high and multiple offers are exchanged verbally, people remember different things. Putting each proposal in writing keeps everyone honest.
Post-Mediation Settlement Agreement
If you reach agreement, document it immediately:
'MEDIATION SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT. Date: [date]. Parties: [names]. Mediator: [name]. Dispute: [brief description]. Terms: [numbered list of all agreed terms, as specific as possible]. Payment: [amount, method, deadline]. Confidentiality: [scope of confidentiality agreement]. Release: [what claims are being released]. Enforcement: [how the agreement will be enforced if a party doesn't comply — typically filed with the court]. This agreement is binding and enforceable. Signed: [signatures of both parties and mediator].'
Sign the settlement agreement before leaving the mediation session. Parties who agree to 'draft something later' often find that the agreement falls apart once they leave the room and talk to friends, family, or lawyers.
When Mediation Fails
If mediation doesn't result in agreement: 'Dear [Other Party], I participated in mediation in good faith and I'm disappointed we weren't able to reach agreement. I remain open to direct settlement discussions if your position changes. However, I want to be transparent: I intend to pursue [next step — filing a lawsuit, arbitration, other remedy] if we cannot resolve this matter by [date]. I believe mediation was the best path to a fair outcome for both of us. If you'd like to revisit any of the proposals discussed during mediation, I'm available to talk.'
Keep the door open after failed mediation. Settlement discussions often resume in the weeks following mediation, when both parties have had time to reflect on the mediator's observations and the costs of continued litigation.
Top comments (0)